John Jackson Kirkland—“Bushwhackin’ John”—was my blood cousin, and the Kirkland boys belong in my family’s story. John served as a Confederate second lieutenant before becoming known as a leader of the Kirkland Bushwhackers in the mountains of East Tennessee and western North Carolina. Following his story takes me straight into the same family as Bas and Rebecca Shaw, where Confederate service, Union loyalty and guerrilla violence divided close kin. I want that history told with the records beside it, including the parts that remain disputed.
How John connects to my family
John was the son of Benjamin Kirkland and Eppie Caroline Kirkland, whose name also appears as Epsie. His maternal grandparents were James Kirkland Sr., born about 1781 and deceased before November 1867, and Susanna “Susan” Kirkland, born about 1786 and living after 1860. Eppie Caroline was the sister of Rebecca “Becca” Kirkland Shaw, wife of Bazel “Bas” Shaw.
That sister relationship connects John to my family. John was Rebecca’s nephew, Bas’s nephew by marriage, and a first cousin of their children. Through Rebecca’s descendants, he was my first cousin five times removed, at Grade B. My connection runs through Rebecca; John belongs in the collateral branch of my bloodline. The census correlations and sworn Eastern Cherokee application statements supporting that connection are presented in the family evidence below; use of those statements does not establish Cherokee ancestry or tribal citizenship.
Three brothers in Vaughn’s 3rd Tennessee
John and his younger brothers James Madison “Jim” Kirkland and Benjamin William “Bill” Kirkland served in Company B, 3rd Tennessee Infantry, Confederate States Army, originally commanded by Colonel John C. Vaughn. The brothers’ wartime paths need to be followed individually; a regiment’s later movements cannot stand in for each man’s service record.
John was elected a junior second lieutenant on May 29, 1861, and served in Virginia during the regiment’s first year. The regiment participated in First Manassas on July 21, 1861. That unit history does not by itself prove John’s personal participation in the fighting. The NPS Vicksburg transcription now confirms entries for James Kirkland, corporal, and William Kirkland, private, both in Company B. Their identification as the brothers rests on the correlated family evidence. See the recorded names and remaining identity limits.
Reorganization, not a documented desertion charge
John’s contemporary military paperwork places the vacancy in his officer position at the regiment’s May 14, 1862 reorganization, with J. T. McAfee succeeding him. On May 17, John described himself under oath as a former second lieutenant and gave Four Mile Branch, Monroe County, as his post office. That affidavit and its accompanying $80 voucher are reproduced below.
I can follow John’s departure through the contemporary paperwork. The surviving nineteen-image service jacket does not document a formal desertion charge. Its reorganization record should therefore be distinguished from later narratives that call John a deserter. It also predates the reported December 1863 burning of the Kirkland gristmill on Turkey Creek, an event sometimes offered as the reason for his departure. The chronology does not support that explanation for the end of his commission.
Comparing the original records also corrected the proposed shared-Vicksburg story. Israel T. Hollingshead’s retained record identifies Company C, 39th North Carolina Infantry, and a November 1862 discharge—not the 43rd Tennessee service attributed to him in the report. John’s May 1862 officer vacancy and Bas’s March 1863 discharge likewise prevent me from placing them together at the July 1863 surrender. Related men and intersecting unit histories do not establish a shared battle, meeting or captivity. See the Shaw profile and its retained evidence.
The Kirkland Bushwhackers
After leaving regular service, my cousin John became known as a leader of the Kirkland Bushwhackers. Local histories associate the band with ambushes, raids and killings around Tellico Plains, Turkey Creek, Citico Creek and the Unicoi Mountains, extending into adjoining western North Carolina. This is the mountain-war setting in which the Kirkland boys appear in the historical accounts. It does not tell me who was present at every raid or who fired a particular shot.
William was also associated with John in accounts of the later mountain conflict, and the brothers were subsequently named together in a murder indictment. The band’s exact membership and each man’s role in particular incidents require separate evidence; neither association with the band nor kinship alone establishes responsibility for a killing.
The Shaw family: divided loyalties and devastating losses
Bas Shaw had served as a Confederate private in Company D, 59th Tennessee Infantry, and his retained service jacket records his discharge at Vicksburg on March 22, 1863. That gives him a documented connection to Vicksburg before the siege. It does not place him in the May–July siege or at the July surrender. Later accounts describe him returning home and assisting Union troops as a civilian scout. His sons followed different wartime paths: James Washington “Jim” Shaw served in Company K, 11th Tennessee Volunteer Cavalry, United States Army; Jefferson “Jeff” Shaw was a pro-Union civilian.
Jim was killed by guerrillas at Cane Creek in early 1864. An 1885 pension examiner described Jefferson as a civilian killed for his Union principles. Later regional accounts attribute the brothers’ deaths to Kirkland’s bushwhackers. If that attribution is correct, members of the band killed their leader’s own first cousins. John’s personal participation in either death has not been established.
Bas’s death belongs to a distinct account. According to the retrospective “Affair at Toqua” narrative, Confederate scouts under Captain William R. Abbott captured Bas and his teenage son Joe Berry near Little Toqua Creek on December 7, 1864. Joe Berry was released; Bas remained a prisoner. The account places Bas’s shooting on December 8 as his captors took him toward Asheville, and his burial near the place remembered as Shaw Grave Gap.
The grave marker preserves that capture and destination, names Rebecca, and records the losses of Jeff and Jim. The attributions must remain separate: Abbott’s scouts are named in Bas’s capture and death; Kirkland’s bushwhackers are named in the reported killings of his sons. The evidence does not establish that John personally killed Bas, Jim or Jeff.
These were people in my own extended family, on different sides of the war and caught in its violence. The connection makes the story personal, but it does not settle disputed events. I am preserving the accounts of Bas, Jim and Jeff alongside the records, with their different sources and limits clear.
Bas Shaw’s grave marker, photographed in its woodland setting. The inscription names Abbott’s scouts in the capture account and Kirkland bushwhackers in the deaths of Jeff and Jim.Narrative source: Bill Baker, “Affair at Toqua”, correlated with the military and family records below. The December 7–8 sequence and named-perpetrator accounts are retrospective, Grade C.
Postwar life and family legacy
John survived the war and lived in western North Carolina, with records associated with Cherokee, Swain and Graham Counties. He had married Julia Ann Giles in Monroe County in August 1848; after her death, he married Martha L. Washam in Blount County on October 14, 1878. Census and marriage records, together with his descendants’ Eastern Cherokee applications, preserve the later family history.
In October 1901, John applied from Reliance, Polk County, for a Tennessee Confederate soldier’s pension, S3751. The application was rejected. Two comrades nevertheless attested to his lieutenant service in Virginia. His late account of how his service ended must be read alongside the contemporary reorganization paperwork and sworn 1862 affidavit; the earlier records provide the firmer chronology.
John died in November 1902. His Confederate marker in the Reliance/Greasy Creek area gives November 16 and identifies Company B, 3rd Tennessee Infantry. The portraits, grave markers and original records below preserve both his family life and the controversies surrounding his wartime reputation.
For me, John’s story belongs beside the lives of his brothers and the losses suffered by the Shaw family. He was my blood cousin, and his history is part of mine. The service records, family statements and court papers let me tell that story without turning an accusation into a conviction or a family connection into proof of an individual act.
The brothers · military records
Jim and Bill at Vicksburg
The National Park Service’s Vicksburg parole transcription lists James Kirkland, corporal, and William Kirkland, private, both in Company B, 3rd Tennessee Infantry, as field parolees. These entries support the reported service of John’s brothers James Madison and Benjamin William. The list supplies their recorded names, ranks and company; identifying each man by his full civilian name still depends on the family and service-record correlation.
Source: National Park Service, Confederate Parole Records — K, checked 11 November 2026. This is a repository transcription; the individual original parole cards have not been newly retrieved for this update.
The same list contains a separate J. C. Kirkland in Company B and a Jesse “Kirkling,” sergeant in Company B, 59th Tennessee Infantry, paroled at the hospital. Neither entry is assigned to John Jackson or to another family member here. John’s own commission had ended in May 1862, and Bas Shaw’s service jacket records his discharge in March 1863.
James Madison “Jim” Kirkland
The supplied research places Jim’s birth about 1830–1832 and his death in 1886. He married Mary C. “Polly” Roberts in Monroe County in 1855. In the Anna Rodgers case, Jim and Polly appear in witness-cost records; John and William appear as defendants. The cost entries do not preserve the witnesses’ testimony.
The report’s specific death day, 20 July 1886, and reported Howard Cemetery burial remain secondary-source details awaiting record or marker confirmation. Research profile.
Benjamin William “Bill” Kirkland
The supplied report identifies a North Carolina death certificate for B. W. Kirkland, born 13 September 1835 and deceased 5 February 1918 at Forney Creek, Swain County. Its published transcription names Ben Kirkland and Epsie Kirkland as his parents. That is useful sibling evidence for the Ben–Eppie household.
Certificate transcription and research profile, reference 344, FHL film 4215342. The certificate image was not independently read for this website update. Reported burial at Bushnell and later reinterment at Lauada require comparison with the burial records.
East Tennessee & western North Carolina
The mountain war, account by account
The new research adds a wider regional chronology to the service records and court papers. The events below come from identified historical accounts. Their placement on a timeline does not establish John’s presence or personal responsibility in every incident.
2 September 1864
Robert Stratton and Jack Roberts
The Graham County Historical Association’s July 2021 newsletter, drawing on Marshall McClung’s account, attributes an ambush near Ball Play to the Kirklands. It describes paper laid in the road as a lure and a dispute over Stratton’s Spencer rifle. Stratton died at the scene; Roberts reportedly died two days later. This is a retrospective narrative.
3 October 1864
Lyon’s men and the Jesse Kirkland conflict
Robert A. Barker’s Union regimental history places killings by Lyon’s Company C around Goldmine–Rock Creek and Stump Ford. The report associates John Stratton and Tom Mashburn with this episode and identifies a Jesse Kirkland killed at Stump Ford. Other accounts give a different place, perpetrator or relationship for Jesse; those differences remain open below.
7–8 December 1864
Bas Shaw’s last journey
The “Affair at Toqua” account places Bas’s capture by Captain W. R. Abbott’s Confederate scouts on 7 December and his death the following day, during movement toward Asheville. His son Joe Berry was released. The existing Shaw evidence and grave-marker photograph preserve the distinctions between Bas’s death and those of his sons Jim and Jeff.
15 January 1865, reported
Captain Joseph C. Gray
Barker reports that Gray, of the Union 3rd Tennessee Mounted Infantry, was killed by bushwhackers near his home. The specific January date and the stories of captured boots and later celebrations are supplied by later accounts and local tradition. They are not treated as independently established acts by John.
12 March 1865, alleged offense
Anna Rodgers
The January 1866 indictment names John and William Kirkland with three other defendants in Anna Rodgers’s killing. The surviving case papers and 13 May 1868 order show prosecution and eventual placement on the retired docket. They establish no conviction or acquittal.
14 May 1865
Paroles at Thomas’s Store
The GCHA newsletter places Major Stephen Whitaker’s issuance of Confederate paroles at Thomas’s Store on this date. This closes the regional chronology; it is not evidence that John personally received one of those paroles.
Sources supplied with BUSHWHACKIN: GCHA Newsletter, July 2021; Barker, Third Tennessee Mounted Infantry, USA; Bill Baker, “Affair at Toqua”. The Union mounted regiment is distinct from John’s Confederate 3rd Tennessee Infantry.
Local traditions and what remains unverified
Later accounts describe a Citico Creek or Buck Highway ambush, with seven men killed, and a killing on the Mud Gap Trail. A grave-marker photograph for the latter remains in the photograph collection. Names, dates and individual responsibility require separate corroboration.
The supplied report also describes an allegation involving a civilian infant near Deals Gap. Its cited archival lead is the Peter H. Prince Papers, University of Tennessee, MS-2921, Box 4, Folder 10. The folder was not read in that investigation, and no contemporary corroborating record was supplied. The allegation remains a research lead, not an established episode in John’s biography.
Barker’s reported accounts of other guerrilla killings in December 1864 and the January 1865 death of Joe Divine provide regional context. They do not, by themselves, identify John or his band as the perpetrators.
Names, dates & competing accounts
Keeping the Kirklands straight
Jesse Kirkland: conflicting accounts
Barker places a Jesse Kirkland’s death at Stump Ford in October 1864, attributed to Lyon’s Union men. The GCHA account attributes a Jesse’s death near Ground Squirrel–Cross Creek to Abbott’s Confederate unit. John Preston Arthur’s 1914 history describes a Jesse, called a kinsman, killed by Lyon’s men on Isaac Carringer’s Creek, without a date. These are retained as competing accounts, not combined into one resolved story.
A Jesse in the Union 3rd Tennessee Mounted Infantry who appears in the 1890 veterans census cannot be a man killed in 1864. The Jesse “Kirkling” in the Vicksburg hospital list and the conflicting Jesse birth dates in compiled family trees also need their own identity comparisons.
- “Turkey-Trot” John
- Arthur describes two Kirklands in the Yellow Creek–Little Tennessee area, distinguishing “Bushwhacker” from “Turkey-Trot” John. His account is an important warning against merging every local John Kirkland. Arthur, 1914, pp. 618–619.
- John’s death: 16 November 1902
- The photographed Confederate marker supports this date. The supplied report found no support for assigning 1903 to John Jackson. Other relatives reportedly died in 1903, but a transfer of their dates onto his biography remains a hypothesis.
- John’s birth: 1827 or October 1828
- The family’s customary 1827 date and the reported October 1828 entry in the 1900 census remain distinct. The website retains the conventional 1827–1902 display with this qualification.
- The 17 April 1858 marriage
- The supplied report attributes this date to William Kirkland and Caroline Carden, a different couple. John and Julia’s August 1848 marriage remains the family’s accepted chronology. The reported correction is a lead to the original marriage entry, not a newly inspected record here.
- William T. Kirkland
- A man reportedly deceased in Maryville in 1916 must not be silently merged with B. W. Kirkland, whose published certificate transcription gives a 1918 death in Swain County. A matching surname or Union service index entry does not settle that identity.
- The two Delilahs and two Rebeccas
- John’s daughter Delilah “Lila” Kirkland Williams is distinct from Delilah Kirkland Hood, reported daughter of Christopher Columbus Kirkland. Rebecca Kirkland Roberts is distinct from Rebecca Kirkland Shaw, through whom Clark’s cousin relationship runs.
Additional same-name exclusions
The report separates John Joseph Kirkland of the 51st Georgia Infantry, John Thornton Kirkland of Harvard, the later Rockwood John J. Kirkland, and the Ohio John J. Kirkland by chronology and locality. The Orange County, North Carolina Southern Claims Commission claimant and Mexican War name matches remain unconnected to John Jackson; those records have not been assigned to him.
The next records
Following the family beyond the existing proof
The accepted cousin relationship remains Grade B, supported by correlated evidence. The family statements already reproduced here establish the framework. Further certificates and estate papers can clarify identities and dates without making an explicit parent–child sentence a requirement for accepting strong indirect proof.
- B. W. Kirkland’s 1918 certificate. Compare the original image with the published transcription naming Ben and Epsie. A death record’s parentage information depends on its informant and must be correlated with the earlier family records.
- Delilah “Lila” Williams, 31 October 1924. Retrieve the Tennessee death certificate for John’s reported daughter, born 31 May 1858. If parents are supplied, it may corroborate the John–Julia household. It would not itself name John’s own parents. Tennessee deaths collection.
- Andrew Jackson Kirkland, 6 June 1930. The submitted research reports an index snippet naming Benjamin and Epsie Caroline. Read the certificate before treating those fields as image-verified evidence.
- Albert C. Kirkland, 7 November 1923. Seek his Idaho death certificate, reported locality Melba, Canyon County, for another independent informant’s account of his parents.
- The 1867–1868 heirs fragment. Locate the underlying court and deed papers, including the reported quitclaims. The uncited “John of N.C.” fragment does not identify John Jackson or name Eppie. Court, case number, book and page remain to be found.
- Burial and commemoration. Compare Greasy Creek, Reliance and Archville locality descriptions with cemetery records. The Chattanooga Daily Times, 29 May 1958, “Confederate Officer to Get Honor at Polk,” is a further source lead.
Andrew’s sworn 26 June 1908 statement in the Hattie D. Lane file identifies James Kirkland as his grandfather. The supplied report treats it as corroboration of the existing family case. Read the file, miscellaneous testimony pp. 625–627. It must be read with the more specific statements already shown in the family proof.
This expansion combines the existing DixieGens evidence collection with the owner-supplied BUSHWHACKIN research report. The NPS entries were checked for this update; certificate transcriptions, snippets, retrospective histories and unread archival targets retain their stated evidence limits. John remains a collateral relative and does not add to the direct-ancestor count.
Photographs and grave markers
The Kirkland brothers
John Kirkland’s grave marker. The inscription names Company B, 3rd Tennessee Infantry, C.S.A., and gives November 16, 1902.
“Here lies an unknown man killed by the Kirkland Bushwhackers.”The Anna Rodgers murder case, 1865–1868
The mountain conflict also reached into the Kirkland and Roberts families through the death of Anna “Ann” Roberts Rodgers. A January 1866 Monroe County grand jury indicted John Kirkland, William Kirkland, Samuel Rodgers, Joseph Phillips and Gale Roberts for first-degree murder, alleging their joint participation in her shooting on March 12, 1865.
John’s brother James Madison Kirkland was married to Mary C. “Polly” Roberts, reported as Anna’s sister. James, Mary and the brothers’ mother Caroline appear in the prosecution’s witness-cost records. Those entries document their involvement as witnesses, but do not preserve what each said.
An arrest warrant issued May 31, 1867 named John and William Kirkland, Samuel Rodgers and Joseph Phillips. The September 7 return records an unsuccessful search and reports that the defendants were said to have fled to North Carolina to bushwhack. The return is evidence of what the officer reported, not a judgment of guilt.
On 13 May 1868, Monroe Circuit Court placed Anna Rodgers murder Case 75 against John and William Kirkland and others on the retired docket after repeated arrest writs were returned with the defendants not found. The State of Tennessee was ordered to pay the costs. This is a documented procedural disposition, not a conviction, acquittal, pardon or nolle prosequi in Case 75. No later reopening or merits judgment was established by the targeted searches; a separate retired-docket register was not retrieved. Read the newly recovered minute entries and original scans.
The court papers put the brothers in different positions: John and William were named as defendants; James appeared in the witness-cost records with his wife. Those distinctions matter. The witness entries do not reveal what they said. The brothers’ Vicksburg parole entries are a separate military source and supply no testimony about this case. I will not fill those gaps with an invented account of guilt, escape or testimony.
View the thirteen-image court collection. Download John Kirkland’s complete illustrated section, including these court records.
Original Confederate military record
May 17, 1862 sworn affidavit
On May 17, 1862, John Kirkland swore to his identity as a former second lieutenant in Company B, 3rd Tennessee Volunteers, and named Four Mile Branch, Monroe County, Tennessee, as his post office. The statement appears beside Voucher No. 12, recording an $80 payment on the same date.
Voucher No. 12, reverse, with sworn identity and post-office statement. Complete image rotated for reading. Open the original scan.Transcription
Personally appeared before me Geo. M. White, an acting Justice of the Peace in and for the County of Knox and State of Tenn., and made oath in due form of law that he is the same John Kirkland who was late 2d Lieut. Co. B, 3 Tenn. Vols.; that the within account is just & true as charged, and that his Post Office [is] Four Mile Branch, Monroe County, Tenn.
Sworn to and subscribed this 17 of May 1862.
John Kirkland
George M. White, a Justice of the Peace for Knox County.
Reading transcription: punctuation and capitalization regularized; [is] supplies an omitted word. The original manuscript controls the reading.
The affidavit directly supports the officer's stated identity, former rank, unit and post-office address. It adds contemporary locality evidence to the civilian-to-officer correlation. It names no parents, wife or Rebecca Shaw; the complete collateral relationship to Clark Hollin Tucker remains Grade B.
Source: National Archives and Records Administration, Record Group 109, War Department Collection of Confederate Records; compiled service record of John Kirkland, Company B, 3rd (Lillard's/Vaughn's) Tennessee Mounted Infantry; M268, roll 126, PI 101, entry 193; Voucher No. 12, reverse, sworn affidavit dated May 17, 1862; digital image 2938 (JKCMSR-2938). NARA archival image 2938. Master pages 813-814; original service-jacket exhibit also on page 771.
Read the affidavit in the complete illustrated appendix
The family connection
Criss Shaw named his mother Becca Kirkland and grandparents James and Susan. Albert Kirkland named his mother Eppie, the same grandparents, and Rebecca among their children. Albert and Andy named John as a brother; Brazel Williams identified his grandparents John and Juliann and traced John to Ben. Julia, Delilah and Susan connect that statement to the original census family.
James and Susan Kirkland
↳ Rebecca Kirkland + Bazel Shaw → S. A. Shaw → Louisa → Grace → Olis Sr. → Olis Jr. → Clark
↳ Eppie Caroline Kirkland + Benjamin Kirkland → John Kirkland
John was Rebecca’s nephew and Bas’s nephew by marriage. He and the Shaw children were first cousins. John was two generations from the shared ancestral couple; Clark was seven. The resulting relationship is first cousin five times removed, supported at Grade B through strong indirect proof.
The “John of North Carolina” identity in the separate 1867–1868 chancery proceedings and older “Jack” references remain unresolved and are not used to establish this route. Remote paternal ancestry and exact dates contain contradictions. These rejected Cherokee claims do not establish Cherokee ancestry, a blood fraction or tribal citizenship. John is a collateral relative; the current register contains 159 direct ancestors, including seven direct Confederate and two direct Union veterans.
Criss C. Shaw, application 26494 · image/page 400

M1104, roll 219; FamilySearch DGS 007153833 · Original source
Criss C. Shaw, application 26494 · image/page 401

M1104, roll 219; FamilySearch DGS 007153833 · Original source
Albert C. Kirkland, application 33702 · image/page 519

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 519; archive zero-based leaf 518 · Original source
Albert C. Kirkland, application 33702 · image/page 520

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 520; archive zero-based leaf 519 · Original source
Brazel Williams, application 33726 · image/page 650

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 650; archive zero-based leaf 649 · Original source
Brazel Williams, application 33726 · image/page 651

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 651; archive zero-based leaf 650 · Original source
Brazel Williams, application 33726 · image/page 652

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 652; archive zero-based leaf 651 · Original source
Andy Kirkland, application 8597 · image/page 806

M1104, roll 87; PDF page 806; archive zero-based leaf 805 · Original source
Andy Kirkland, application 8597 · image/page 807

M1104, roll 87; PDF page 807; archive zero-based leaf 806 · Original source
Confederate military records
The complete retrieved cataloged jacket contains 19 images. The separate 1901 Polk County pension S3751 contains five consecutive images, including its cover. The pension was rejected; two comrades nevertheless attested John’s lieutenant service in Virginia. Its late recollections are weighed against the earlier military paperwork.
Service jacket 1 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2921 · Original source
Service jacket 2 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2922 · Original source
Service jacket 3 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2923 · Original source
Service jacket 4 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2924 · Original source
Service jacket 5 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2925 · Original source
Service jacket 6 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2926 · Original source
Service jacket 7 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2927 · Original source
Service jacket 8 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2928 · Original source
Service jacket 9 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2929 · Original source
Service jacket 10 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2930 · Original source
Service jacket 11 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2931 · Original source
Service jacket 12 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2932 · Original source
Service jacket 13 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2933 · Original source
Service jacket 14 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2934 · Original source
Service jacket 15 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2935 · Original source
Service jacket 16 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2936 · Original source
Service jacket 17 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2937 · Original source
Service jacket 18 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2938 · Original source
Service jacket 19 of 19

M268 roll126; image 2939 · Original source
Pension S3751 · all five images
Pension 1 of 5

Tennessee State Library and Archives; image 615 · Original source
Pension 2 of 5

Tennessee State Library and Archives; image 616 · Original source
Pension 3 of 5

Tennessee State Library and Archives; image 617 · Original source
Pension 4 of 5

Tennessee State Library and Archives; image 618 · Original source
Pension 5 of 5

Tennessee State Library and Archives; image 619 · Original source
The illustrated master section
The retained 100-page collection contains the original exhibits and earlier analysis. The updated brothers’ research and chronology are presented on this webpage above.
The download now contains the revised first-person story on master page 743, together with every retained page of family proof and original exhibits. The expanded web narrative uses the same evidence qualifications; the separate operational comparison remains on master page 869.
The expanded 100-page illustrated volume includes the earlier family and service section, ten pages of Shaw testimony, the recovered-research review, and sixteen pages documenting the 1868 court disposition and military-record checks. The web gallery below preserves the existing exhibits and adds the new original records.
Download John’s complete illustrated section · 100 pages
The download preserves every page, citation and exhibit from the master’s John Kirkland section. Images are optimized for web viewing; original-source links and preserved-original checksums accompany the exhibits.
Documentary verdict
DECISIVE DOCUMENTS: Criss C. Shaw application 26494, NARA M1104 roll 219, FamilySearch DGS 007153833 images 400-402; Albert C. Kirkland application 33702, M1104 roll 267, Internet Archive PDF pages 519-521; Brazel Williams application 33726, same roll, PDF pages 650-652; Andy Kirkland application 8597, M1104 roll 87, PDF pages 806-810; Andrew Kirkland testimony, 26 June 1908, M685 roll 7, p.626, DGS 007156108 image 617. Civil census/marriage exhibits and the controlling master identify the intervening people. John Kirkland CMSR, M268 roll 126, NARA item 180231298, images 2921-2939, and Tennessee pension S3751, FamilySearch images 615-619, document the military man.
COMPETING IDENTITIES EXCLUDED: Rebecca Kirkland Roberts, born about 1837, is a daughter in the Ben-Eppie generation, not Rebecca Kirkland Shaw. Albert and Andy place their paternal grandfather John/Jack above Benjamin: that older man is not their brother John. The young Benjamin, age 22 in the 1850 neighboring household, is not silently made the father of an adult John born about 1827. The target is identified through Julia Ann and the Delilah/Susan family cluster, rather than through a common forename alone. John Haulk and the North Carolina legal defendant have not been comprehensively identified; their full identities remain unresolved, and neither is used as the connecting ancestor.
REMAINING UNCERTAINTIES: the identity and legal role of John of N.C.; the exact man meant by older Jack references; the inaccessible 1867-1868 chancery case; remote Kirkland ancestry above the shared James-Susan couple; conflicting dates and some sibling names; precise responsibility and dates in the Shaw killings; the portrait's original provenance. These limits do not supply the essential steps in the independently established nephew route. No second cousin relationship or great-granduncle relationship is admitted.
A complete indirect proof argument
1. Identify Rebecca through her own son and grandson
Criss C. Shaw, born 24 January 1853, identifies his father as Baze Shaw and his mother as Becca Shaw, maiden name Kirkland (26494, image 400). On image 401 he names his maternal grandparents James Kirkland and Susan Kirkland and their children James, John, Epie, Jessie, Criss, Becca, Riss, Wm and Andy. Image 402 again names his mother Becca and her father James. This is firsthand knowledge of his parental household and retrospective knowledge of grandparents. It independently supplies the maternal couple missing from Frank A. Shaw 29621, whose grandparents were Baze and Rebecca and whose Q22 also names Rebecca's father James. Sarrell Shaw's 1932 death registration and the 1850/1860 household strengthen the same-person identification. [NEW-26494-400/401/402; GM-0198/0199; VITAL-23884]
2. Identify Eppie through her sons, not a secondary tree
Albert C. Kirkland 33702 names Benjamin and Eppie Kirkland as his parents (PDF p.519). His maternal grandparents are James Kirkland and Susan (p.520). In the list specifically headed James Kirkland's children, he names John, James, Jes, Criss, Wm, Andy, Lizzie, Rebecca and Eppie. The overlapping cluster, same place and same parental couple distinguish this family from a chance match on James alone. Criss names Epie among his mother Becca's siblings; Albert names Rebecca among his mother Eppie's siblings. This reciprocal evidence from sons of the two women supports full sisterhood at B. [NEW-33702-519/520]
3. Correlate Eppie, Caroline and Eppie Caroline
Andy Kirkland 8597 names his parents Ben and Caroline Kirkland (PDF p.806) and his maternal grandparents Jim Kirkland and Susie Baston (p.807). In his sworn 1908 testimony, Andrew names the same parents Ben and Eppie Caroline and the maternal grandfather James. His birth year, place and family cluster correlate Andy with Andrew. Albert's Eppie and Andy's Caroline are thus supported as the same woman by the combined name in the later testimony, not assumed from a similar forename. Susan/Susie with the James/Jim partner is independently supported from the Rebecca and Eppie branches. The surname reading Baston is supported by Andy and Eliza Linn; expanded spellings Bastian/Boston are variants to investigate, not separately proved birth names. [NEW-8597-806/807; KIR-617; LINN-251]
4. Establish John as a son of Ben and Eppie
Albert lists John first among his own brothers and sisters; Andy likewise lists John among his siblings and reports a death in 1903 (PDF p.807). These original family statements supply the previously missing son in the Ben-Eppie family. They do not rely on a tree importing John. The year 1903 conflicts with the usual 1902 death attribution and is not silently corrected; it is a retrospective date discrepancy, while the immediate sibling relationship is repeated. [NEW-33702-520; NEW-8597-807]
5. Distinguish that John through his daughter and wife
Brazel Williams 33726 names his parents Wm Williams and Delilah, maiden name Kirkland (PDF p.650), and maternal grandparents John Kirkland and Juliann Kirkland (p.651). He lists their children Sarah, Caroline, Delilah, Susan, Lee, Wm and Minnie. In Q22 he explicitly traces his mother Delilah to John and John to Ben (p.652). The wife Juliann and daughters Delilah and Susan match the 1860 Monroe and 1870 North Carolina John-Julia households; the combination is far more discriminating than name or state alone. The 1848 Julia Ann Giles marriage license supplies the surname. This connects the married civilian John to the Ben family whose son Albert names Eppie as mother. Rebecca Roberts and Andy Kirkland witness Brazel's application; that strengthens family association but also reduces source independence. [NEW-33726-650/651/652; original civil exhibits]
6. Correlate the civilian, officer and historical subject
The same John-Julia household moves from Monroe to western North Carolina. The 1878 John-Martha L. Washam marriage and 1880/1900 North Carolina households provide a qualified later sequence, with age, initial and birthplace variations retained. The 1901 Reliance, Polk County, pension S3751 identifies John Kirkland of Company B, 3rd Tennessee Infantry, and reports only about 14 months' current Tennessee residence. Two former comrades, Daniel Rymer and S. E. A. Rymer, say they served with him in Virginia when he was a lieutenant in the 3rd Tennessee. This agrees with the original officer jacket's unit and Virginia service and the historical identification of the borderland leader. The pension does not name his wife or parents and is corroboration, not a standalone birth or household record. Bill Baker's published Affair at Toqua also specifically identifies William Williams's wife Delilah as the bushwhacker leader's daughter; that secondary identification matches the original Brazel Williams family statement and the census daughter cluster. It is contextual corroboration, not an original sworn identification of the nickname. The civilian-to-officer identification is B by combined chronology, locality, family sequence and service details, rather than A from a single explicit bridge. [JKPEN-617/618/619; JKCMSR-2921 through 2939]
7. Evaluate independence and competing explanations
Criss, Albert, Andy and Brazel are separate family informants. They share an eligibility proceeding, some witnesses and the preparer Geo. W. Isbill, so their statements are not counted as four wholly independent ancestral traditions. Their immediate relationships nevertheless come from different positions in the family: a son of Rebecca, sons of Eppie, and a grandson of John and Julia. The independent census households, marriage records, military paperwork and 1885 Shaw testimony constrain their identities. A copied remote Cherokee tradition is less reliable than convergent immediate family identification. No evidence located indicates an adoptive or step relationship in the essential line; ordinary stated parent-child relationships support the biological conclusion at B.
8. Resolve the route and calculate only after establishing it
James and Susan had daughters Rebecca and Eppie; Eppie and Benjamin had John. Therefore John was Rebecca's nephew and Bazel Shaw's nephew by marriage. Rebecca's son S. A. Shaw and John were first cousins. Clark descends five further parent-child steps from S. A. The common ancestral couple is two generations above John and seven above Clark: min(2,7)-1 = 1st cousin; |7-2| = five removals. The result is FIRST COUSIN FIVE TIMES REMOVED, Grade B. It is recalculated from these records, not retained merely because an earlier report asserted it.
Contradictions and limits retained in the proof
Brazel's Q22 extends Ben's father as James, whereas Albert names his paternal grandfather John with Jackson written above and Andy's supplement refers to Jack and Sarah Shelton. The remote paternal extension is contradictory and remains C; it is not needed to establish John's immediate parents or his maternal connection to Rebecca. No proposed Nathan father is substituted for these original answers. No second-cousin-five-times-removed route is admitted.
Eliza Linn reports her father James died in 1872; Caroline Kirkland 18825 reports 1873; Rebecca's brother James was alive and testified in 1885. Those men or death statements are not silently merged. The decisive reciprocal sisterhood argument comes from Criss and Albert, rather than requiring Caroline's father to equal the 1885 witness. Their James-Susan grandparent cluster is useful corroboration, while that particular James identity remains unresolved.
The 1850 James, 67, and Susan, 64, live beside the Shaw family and a matching Kirkland cluster. This supports the parental-couple identification but is not itself a relationship statement. Exact birth dates and every child's identity are not established by that census. Albert's Lizzie and Criss's Riss may be distinct people or a naming/recall variation; no automatic merger is made.
The conventional lifespan 1827-1902 varies from the 1900 census birth month/year October 1828 and Andy's 1903 death report. These variations remain qualified. The 1901 pension also reports Jackson County, N.C., as birthplace despite its opening Tennessee-native wording. It records memory impairment described by a physician. Its late recollections of enlistment in April 1861 and leaving at Lee's surrender do not override the contemporary May/June 1861 enrollment/muster and May 1862 officer vacancy.
A rejected Guion Miller application proves that a claim was made; it does not prove Cherokee ancestry or tribal citizenship. The immediate family relationships can be useful even when remote ancestry and eligibility claims fail. No Cherokee fraction, enrollment or citizenship conclusion is made.
The original 1867-1868 case remains inaccessible after two distinct routes. The 1873 legal John remains C. Neither is a necessary premise of this proof. The missing Uncle Jack passage in Frank's application is a corrected citation error, not a hidden substitute for the new son-and-grandson evidence.
Eight independent relationship grades
1. Rebecca paternity | B
James Kirkland: her son Criss names him, grandson Frank agrees, and the reciprocal James-Susan sibling cluster and neighboring 1850 household discriminate the family. Exact dates remain qualified.
2. Rebecca maternity | B
Susan Kirkland: Criss directly names his maternal grandmother; Albert names the same couple and Rebecca as Eppie's sister. Susie Baston is supported through Andy's matching maternal couple and Eliza's separate statement. Bastian/Boston spellings are not independently proved.
3. Epsie Caroline parentage | B
James and Susan: Albert's maternal grandparents and child list, Andy's Jim/Susie Baston, Andrew's 1908 Eppie Caroline statement and Criss's reciprocal sibling list.
4. John paternity | B
Benjamin/Ben: Brazel identifies grandfather John, husband of Juliann, as Ben's son; Albert and Andy identify brother John in their Ben family.
5. John maternity | B
Eppie Caroline: Albert names Eppie as his mother and John as brother; Andy names Caroline and brother John; Andrew supplies the combined name. The John-Julia/Delilah bridge identifies the target family.
6. John of N.C. | C
The 1873 order lacks identifying wife, age and precise North Carolina county; the original 1867 case was not retrieved. No automatic target identification.
7. Uncle Jack | C
Absent as such from Frank 29621. Eliza's Jack is her grandfather's brother; Andy's paternal Jack is a grandfather. Neither is equated with the younger target.
8. Complete John-Clark biological relationship | B
First cousin five times removed through James-Susan, Eppie-John and Rebecca's six-edge admitted descent to Clark. Independent historical perpetrator claims are not upgraded by this grade.
Controlling-master relationship chart
G6 → G5
Rebecca [r075] and Baze/Bazell [r074] → S. A. Shaw/Shew [r061]. Existing B; master pages 60 and 441, links B030/B031. Frank’s 1907 application and Sarrell’s 1932 parental record were independently inspected.
G5 → G4
S. A. Shaw/Shew [r061] → Louisa “Lou” Shew [r022]. Existing A; master page 440, B026. Sources include the 1900 daughter household, 1910 in-law household, 1936 death information and Frank’s 1907 sibling list.
G4 → G3
Louisa [r022] → Grace Hollingshead [r009]. Existing A/B; master page 439, B023. Sources include the 1904 marriage and 1910 family household; record plates on pages 43-45, 49, 51, 53-54 and 57-58.
G3 → G2
Grace [r009] → Olis Creed Tucker Sr. [r005]. Existing A/B; master page 435, B008, with 1930/1940 census exhibits on pages 205-206 and 480-481.
G2 → G1
Olis Creed Tucker Sr. [r005] → Olis Creed Tucker Jr. [r002]. Existing family and 1950-census admission; master page 435, B005; sources on pages 204 and 467.
G1 → G0
Olis Creed Tucker Jr. [r002] → Clark Hollin Tucker [r000]. Existing family and private vital-record admission; master page 434, B002; private certificate on page 466. Living-person documents remain in the private master and are not republished on the public website.
Established collateral junction | B
James and Susan Kirkland -> Eppie Caroline -> John; James and Susan -> Rebecca -> S. A. -> Louisa -> Grace -> Olis Sr. -> Olis Jr. -> Clark. John was Rebecca's nephew; Bas's nephew by marriage; first cousin to Bas and Rebecca's children; Clark's first cousin five times removed.
Scope of validation
The pedigree review used the 737-page pre-update master, identified by SHA-256 7615840c1094c6c07501a40feab68ebc75bb99fd62782879004418e7ab8d3f80. Its register contained 140 admitted ancestors plus Clark and 18 held candidates, 159 profiles in all. The final 1 November 2026 edition supersedes that historical source edition. No alleged 207-person or v9 master was established.
The six Rebecca-Clark edges and profile IDs remain unchanged. The new collateral connection is supported at B. That collateral review added no direct-ancestor register rows; its historical baseline was 140. The separate current incorporation brings the register to 159 ancestors plus Clark. John is an additional collateral Confederate relative, not an eighth direct Confederate veteran.
Final adversarial audit
Could John of N.C. be a different John?
Yes; identity remains C and is not used as an essential step.
Could Uncle Jack be a great-uncle or older relative?
Yes. The inspected wording places Jack in older generations. The brother/nephew decision is established by the new applications instead.
Could Benjamin-Epsie be only a tree error?
No longer merely a tree claim: Albert, Andy and Brazel provide the independently correlated original family statements. Their remote ancestry remains disputed.
Could the brother theory misread heirs?
Yes. The original pleading is unavailable and legal heirship does not necessarily mean siblinghood. The identified John is a nephew through Eppie in the new evidence.
Does the 1867 case identify Susanna as Rebecca's mother?
Not established; no original inspection claimed. The maternity finding rests on Criss, Albert and Andy instead.
Are the sources copying the same account?
Some common tradition is likely, particularly for remote Cherokee ancestry. Shared preparer and witnesses are acknowledged. Immediate family statements are constrained by independent civil, military and pension processes.
Does every generation match the master?
Yes, using its existing admitted chain and grades, with original Frank/Sarrell evidence additionally inspected here. This is not a fresh exhaustive re-proof of every living-person vital event.
Is the calculation correct?
Yes: John is two and Clark seven generations from the shared parents of Rebecca and Eppie. First cousin, five removals. A great-granduncle designation would require the contrary brother route; it is not used.
The complete retrieved military files
All 19 images of the cataloged John Kirkland Confederate compiled service jacket are preserved and reproduced: NARA RG109, M268 roll 126, item 180231298, images 2921-2939, Company B, 3rd (Lillard's/Vaughn's) Tennessee Infantry. The file documents junior second-lieutenant service and an officer vacancy at the May 1862 reorganization. This is the entire retrieved cataloged jacket, not a claim that no separate military record survives elsewhere.
Pension S3751 is preserved in all five consecutive images 615-619, with the following different claimant at image 620 confirming the boundary. John applied at Reliance, Polk County, on 26 October 1901; it was filed 28 October. The application is stamped REJECTED. A note says pensionability required proof that the condition resulted from service. Rejection is not evidence that he never served. Two comrades attest his lieutenant service in Virginia. The complete file is reproduced, including its cover, rather than selected favorable pages.
Original forms retain their recorded names, including John or Jno. His guerrilla leadership is a historical identification; the service jacket does not itself document individual bushwhacking incidents or establish culpability for the Shaw deaths.
Military and family record exhibit register · 55 images
1. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2921

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2921 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: eed70d3cc2a502194eec1207f872f270dbefd3b080d4a2d8aae712f372f909be
2. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2922

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2922 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 486efc8e1716076797ceef3852fc5a0c08a913938a6d0acb7c9ebdfbe9703024
3. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2923

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2923 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 0bcbb0162b73fa5aa14c1dc664eb6cee97c78db048cb57bdb5ad534b5de09ee5
4. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2924

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2924 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 7ef60d232006e82a205e54ace0dc521f60c5eed02ce218c11ccf65297696bba2
5. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2925

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2925 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: f8bb81948c25060c9e9578ce79c51219f1c233405990524c671a5f6233cce16d
6. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2926

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2926 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 9cde6db6e78aa29443d840996d0b070d3d4fbe927943c4e3db58b389194d780e
7. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2927

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2927 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: baa1a0769e9472a6b45e1479ef19af495822e261afe1117c2a04c30e98640d10
8. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2928

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2928 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 06e12efad47fc2359359fb9c963ca118e2fd26d52ea917952ee46a0818501f6d
9. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2929

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2929 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 7ef488b5c4b75dcff23101ad3015652c541bf17067f7767ecb064ad463985574
10. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2930

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2930 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: e2ed2df3fc1da580093867b76f9b4022c6b92473b1161850393a5488fe4023f2
11. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2931

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2931 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: de5b5f551a03c01a0d90903964e7b4c61dffc86aa5e38a5f4f6d03e5170cc53c
12. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2932

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2932 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 9cf6da9558dc72d20325a874f014b61fa4dbe99d7013937693b4c63397df16a4
13. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2933

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2933 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: d63afe9975a10be219cba2ac745ccf05f905f740198dc9d53ab30d3a0d28121f
14. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2934

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2934 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 989a5517a2a006dc93e9e534d6597f07a6c62bf1b6f58d4655b83e287fd1de7a
15. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2935

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2935 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 60bc4ce03aecee96e4dfe46072e91bf7cf09e679f9fae35a247f842f617f4457
16. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2936

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2936 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: cede5737d485a6ae9270cbe85858466b1960a89b89e8bc37583d8c36715b6219
17. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2937

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2937 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: bd988bcaad9e9e5345fb01ef020cfee1076e9c29d507817bc6811302b07c01e1
18. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2938

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2938 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: f49a9b6b60563c5842e9de27c1e83d547383700564127d2353a11e8044e33034
19. John Kirkland Confederate service jacket · JKCMSR-2939

M268 roll126; PI101 entry193; Co.B,3rd (Lillard's) Tennessee; 19-image jacket; image/page 2939 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: f9c9cd277c828a8205900de772b4ff9c3a2e753e0c3070253366ad5251ce4a9a
20. John Kirkland, Polk County Confederate pension S3751 · JKPEN-615

Tennessee State Library and Archives; Soldier applications 3701-3755; image/page 615 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: bff72c59dd6c820051a319fd98963583a3af96d4a1f92703c651c0ff91fdf547
21. John Kirkland, Polk County Confederate pension S3751 · JKPEN-616

Tennessee State Library and Archives; Soldier applications 3701-3755; image/page 616 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 232f562bbc21bdc94c1fd2c12f833fc57ba78fd6d5acb7d7f0a42d829eaf1d65
22. John Kirkland, Polk County Confederate pension S3751 · JKPEN-617

Tennessee State Library and Archives; Soldier applications 3701-3755; image/page 617 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 04ffc4a9d95af974e40ebba3e8ef2380fe5ee8538c67793744e30ec6226e3cf4
23. John Kirkland, Polk County Confederate pension S3751 · JKPEN-618

Tennessee State Library and Archives; Soldier applications 3701-3755; image/page 618 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 045cb26d7153e3dcce1980bc6f2b24fb4dd599f3046ff7a569c6f5d3fad9b3d0
24. John Kirkland, Polk County Confederate pension S3751 · JKPEN-619

Tennessee State Library and Archives; Soldier applications 3701-3755; image/page 619 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 8c23f699c86671f44f83418bf3e860e2f1a362925e21598026d9e0dad5be4b59
25. Criss C. Shaw, application 26494 · NEW-26494-400

M1104, roll 219; FamilySearch DGS 007153833; image/page 400 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 83392bcad350d99dadb51662b6814766745378be55bae062cad460fe28e3072f
26. Criss C. Shaw, application 26494 · NEW-26494-401

M1104, roll 219; FamilySearch DGS 007153833; image/page 401 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: f4fb072f257e1ca30fd754b5a8f9d68ba12d20377792519b9616ecfb39f3b05d
27. Criss C. Shaw, application 26494 · NEW-26494-402

M1104, roll 219; FamilySearch DGS 007153833; image/page 402 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 484c9cea2d9ba60717aa761846a60cdf11d58f7be62af551082e946ed391dc09
28. Albert C. Kirkland, application 33702 · NEW-33702-519

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 519; archive zero-based leaf 518; image/page 519 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: e491b01d18a6e05a7edd3b3e11aaec8d78000a9fe105e441bf76f83f795e643c
29. Albert C. Kirkland, application 33702 · NEW-33702-520

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 520; archive zero-based leaf 519; image/page 520 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 997f46ea70f3aaa3d1213e138a6d839e57d6490657ae92449d1a3b5421cc2894
30. Albert C. Kirkland, application 33702 · NEW-33702-521

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 521; archive zero-based leaf 520; image/page 521 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 3d6ae306fad33da56d1323d6388457c9e9efcc9031af8de0e343e6c2ff0ba188
31. Brazel Williams, application 33726 · NEW-33726-650

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 650; archive zero-based leaf 649; image/page 650 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 002ca9562c7319d76cfe05d1a2457a412cb92ac4b7f35a596a81d082fc1c8d4b
32. Brazel Williams, application 33726 · NEW-33726-651

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 651; archive zero-based leaf 650; image/page 651 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 71d4e48bf8afb35a1874c049248c487c0e1b222d5c3753a25ae08ead023acaba
33. Brazel Williams, application 33726 · NEW-33726-652

M1104, roll 267; PDF page 652; archive zero-based leaf 651; image/page 652 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 54af3dd5b346b991380b0c9ac0a994f93576cef5c062c2c6624e3ee0912089b6
34. Andy Kirkland, application 8597 · NEW-8597-806

M1104, roll 87; PDF page 806; archive zero-based leaf 805; image/page 806 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 2f82af390d66747a871e7afaeef082b4f09b24d5e93ec8dd8b55035bae6a52a4
35. Andy Kirkland, application 8597 · NEW-8597-807

M1104, roll 87; PDF page 807; archive zero-based leaf 806; image/page 807 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 8c61bf24788aad4a991449eb7d66c3012a17acc644b99b26758e337d90de3cb7
36. Andy Kirkland, application 8597 · NEW-8597-810

M1104, roll 87; PDF page 810; archive zero-based leaf 809; image/page 810 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: f464b437d076d82688c6e43016672b55935f6e19e3b56ecab3495fca63e76ed0
37. Frank A. Shaw, Eastern Cherokee application 29621 · GM-0194

M1104 roll 240; FamilySearch DGS 007153852; film 378512; complete six-image packet; image/page 194 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: e725c7cd7bb374736d3e6e4d5f81deba0b3e12f4bb6ee5cd835047dc05ae5885
38. Frank A. Shaw, Eastern Cherokee application 29621 · GM-0195

M1104 roll 240; FamilySearch DGS 007153852; film 378512; complete six-image packet; image/page 195 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 31e41fbdb58dbb657b088b8302b66a22b175d0ca01d4707e0fb6627ad3b88f00
39. Frank A. Shaw, Eastern Cherokee application 29621 · GM-0196

M1104 roll 240; FamilySearch DGS 007153852; film 378512; complete six-image packet; image/page 196 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 52eef362ead24cfcbf43eb570f92086baf55a1dade1ad5e436f6b9cea235bdf4
40. Frank A. Shaw, Eastern Cherokee application 29621 · GM-0197

M1104 roll 240; FamilySearch DGS 007153852; film 378512; complete six-image packet; image/page 197 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 4bffdbd687ad77f687354a3da9e66f2a3feb25ae4c06c087d973f2448cc567c9
41. Frank A. Shaw, Eastern Cherokee application 29621 · GM-0198

M1104 roll 240; FamilySearch DGS 007153852; film 378512; complete six-image packet; image/page 198 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 6b58f1f80a8fc7eb8a091ad8f057df21e37a11fecedfd1ccab332f35c1bd9259
42. Frank A. Shaw, Eastern Cherokee application 29621 · GM-0199

M1104 roll 240; FamilySearch DGS 007153852; film 378512; complete six-image packet; image/page 199 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: e2a68607a6cb8671a98e309af5fed0c57e1bf26bdfe1b69a48e4f393d4956f02
43. Guion Miller miscellaneous Kirkland testimony · KIR-616

M685 roll 7; Volumes 1–2, testimony p. 625; film 830440; DGS 007156108; image/page 616 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 729d2af78d657f7022045c9ceec03b2d5f9c933afcadd9f37c9518498f402c4d
44. Guion Miller miscellaneous Kirkland testimony · KIR-617

M685 roll 7; Volumes 1–2, testimony p. 626; film 830440; DGS 007156108; image/page 617 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: d84f71b3a9b704280365223407d7649377f20a4476d216aed644ab3fd395a064
45. Guion Miller miscellaneous Kirkland testimony · KIR-618

M685 roll 7; Volumes 1–2, testimony p. 627; film 830440; DGS 007156108; image/page 618 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 98b20818a7af8ddaf57601d6e82686663b649a28ea99ac6b2755ecb78aa73a92
46. 1848 Kirkland marriage record · JOHN-1848

; Monroe marriage book 3, p. 62, entry 184; image/page marriage_VRMUSATN1780_070551-00208 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: fb30bb2f6e01422efb8102e030274433a130fef56052e42954a02a5cd2f89e13
47. 1860 Kirkland census · JOHN-1860

M653 roll1265; Monroe TN District 17, p. 223 / stamped 301, HH1616 family1636; image/page 4297407_00608 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 855c9465edf35d3ab05e29a153bbcdca6864ef52bfeea2f5cccb1a0be061bc2d
48. 1870 Kirkland census · JOHN-1870

M593 roll1130; Cheoah, Cherokee NC, p. 11 / stamped265A, HH69; image/page 4277206_00035 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: ce24939ca4646a8f0092177fccf7bce174955fa772db9571fb66fdfa54ae6cb3
49. 1878 Kirkland marriage record · JOHN-1878

; Blount marriages p. 135, entry 6; image/page marriage_VRMUSATN1780_026558-00591 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 3853762a6db57859fa161897eef26407f4cf534fce954565edece8c3e5ee54e7
50. 1880 Kirkland census · JOHN-1880

T9 roll983; Forney Creek, Swain NC, ED182 p.11 / stamped198C, HH100; image/page 4243417-00308 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 252ed037350fda0b1a71e306be83b7553266b9ecf2cb9941e89540d131daff92
51. 1900 Kirkland census · JOHN-1900

T623 roll1196; Yellow Creek, Graham NC, ED19 sheet3B, lines87–88; image/page 4117824_00891 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: ed598f40d535be17632f2bb661db2897b18ffab19c2769fe73a998b1ef141775
52. Eliza Ann Linn Eastern Cherokee application13277 · LINN-251

M1104 roll131; DGS007153780; film378440; complete7-image packet; image/page 251 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: affa4fab98a17e8f2bf02ecc0c806ad5d8fcc230f149493e9cdd61d9a38ae5de
53. Eliza Ann Linn Eastern Cherokee application13277 · LINN-252

M1104 roll131; DGS007153780; film378440; complete7-image packet; image/page 252 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 1eed61b8f0d2d69846f79ccf4d6237f35000f877b6ad8b7853e5f3f9053b2005
54. Caroline Kirkland, application 18825 · NEW-18825-287

M1104, roll 168; PDF page 287; archive zero-based leaf 286; image/page 287 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 03ef15228626b14a32bd809de945ed7994c2ed89439c6e8a468e8b2db3634db3
55. Sarrell Shaw Tennessee death certificate 23884 · VITAL-23884

; 1932 certificate 23884, roll 10; image/page 33113_257967-01391 · Original source
Preserved original SHA-256: 22fd0d8578127bd60f17756a1719b072eb5ff621c8e893a4ff9540e22a7e7244
What the original Shaw records add
The Shaw family in the original records
The war divided this family in ways a list of uniforms cannot explain. My direct ancestor Baze or Bazell Shaw is identified, at Grade B, with the Confederate private whose surviving service jacket records enrollment at Knoxville on January 10, 1862, and discharge at Vicksburg on March 22, 1863. That discharge came before the siege. His service is part of our history, but it does not put him in the later siege or the July surrender.
James went into Union service
His son James Washington Shaw took a different course. A Treasury report dated March 21, 1867, identifies him as a private in Company K, 11th Tennessee Cavalry, enrolled September 20 and mustered October 12, 1863. The report transcribes the company roll as “Captured and Killed Jan. 1st 1864.” James Kirkland and W. H. Linn later described examining his fatal gunshot wounds and helping bury him, attributing his death to guerrillas about February 1, 1864. Those are different dates, and neither document identifies the individual who shot him. The burial testimony establishes what the witnesses saw afterward; it does not make them eyewitnesses to the shooting.
Jefferson was a civilian
The distinction matters just as much for James’s brother Jefferson. In his July 1885 investigation, pension examiner Milton C. Dent explicitly said Jefferson was not in military service and shared James’s fate because of his Union principles. I will not turn him into a soldier to simplify the story. His civilian status makes his death no less part of the family’s wartime loss.
Rebecca’s account, and what remains unresolved
Rebecca told the examiner on July 28, 1885, that her husband was killed in December 1864. Earlier pension paperwork gave a conflicting death account. Later local history reports that Rebels killed him after his discharge; the inspected deposition establishes Rebecca’s account of a killing, but does not itself identify the killers. No inspected original proves John Kirkland personally killed Bazel, James, or Jefferson. That distinction must remain visible even when a later story gives a more definite answer.
What the neighbors remembered
The pension depositions also preserve ordinary life under extraordinary strain. Larkin Cardin remembered that the boys’ father went into the army and asked him to look after three boys, the oldest about sixteen. Cardin supplied corn and meat against their labor. He described Rebecca’s poverty and her small log cabin. James Kirkland identified himself as her brother and said James was her only son in the army. These details show relatives and neighbors trying to keep a household alive, without settling the separate question of who committed the killings.
John’s brothers and the family connection
John Kirkland was Rebecca’s nephew and Bazel’s nephew by marriage. His brothers James Madison and Benjamin William belong in this account as distinct men, not interchangeable names. The NPS parole transcription lists James Kirkland, corporal, and William Kirkland, private, in Company B, 3rd Tennessee Infantry. The brothers’ section explains the correlation with James Madison and Benjamin William and the need to compare the original cards. Those entries cannot extend Bazel’s service beyond his March 1863 discharge.
The Anna Rodgers case after the war
The 1866 indictment concerning Anna Rodgers named John Kirkland, William Kirkland, Samuel Rodgers, Joseph Phillips and Gale Roberts. It records an accusation, not a conviction. A surviving cost bill lists Caroline Kirkline, Mary C. Kirkland and J. M. Kirkline, each for four days and forty miles at $5.60. Those entries are assessed witness costs; they are not payment receipts or testimony about what each person said. A September 1867 return reports that the defendants were not found in the county. That does not establish that they were never arrested or tried at any other time. The 13 May 1868 minutes now document Case 75's removal to the retired docket, with costs charged to Tennessee. This was not a verdict. See the original order and its limits below.
Inspect the records
PEN-0185 — Second Auditor report of military service

Repository source · SHA-256 4eff80750a6e8873b73aa89af50755379aff722b9f2bbf07a4ba8bba64d466bd
PEN-0174 — Affidavit on James W. Shaw burial

Repository source · SHA-256 936870f2c365bfe659f1f008ec5bc5e6ece9b549b4b01b2665847248df684133
PEN-0175 — Affidavit on James W. Shaw burial

Repository source · SHA-256 3fe5ee3f80fba0cfcb37896b5c7a3d5256fb2b2eb1277cd23253975a4109a8d8
PEN-0192 — Milton C. Dent special examiner report

Repository source · SHA-256 f909a14fa13e4a1a91e6a89b681ca2297077c4cd9e03f6bd4c00a963e2b539f1
PEN-0197 — Deposition A, Rebecca Shaw

Repository source · SHA-256 a701fc8ebab16d68ae52f2b84a30bc4d4fc7d1511b4e7ca089fecc66948a7de5
PEN-0201 — Deposition B, Larkin Cardin

Repository source · SHA-256 5f01bb5cd814ead4fdb4a898de7ca116d929b0002a68367c2c6c8cc19f3ce055
PEN-0202 — Deposition B, Larkin Cardin

Repository source · SHA-256 fc9d7de0a1e3af95eeda77e2156a1ef3ec34c6202825513f095c599736f5cc05
PEN-0203 — Deposition C, James Kirkland

Repository source · SHA-256 49169beb59d0208cd1be7f5ffdf9ce8db6b46336c37c0dc63b3d155c05ab1a2e
PEN-0204 — Deposition C, James Kirkland

Repository source · SHA-256 de4fc88abc03f311921b80df6bcec15881462fd5740c47e5dff1b2c3eccc3f8c
CASE75-05 — Monroe County Circuit Court Case 75

Repository source · SHA-256 c76cf700b87d72db61e73df6e836ef831f65d0d7f701a30375e89737b3abb571
CASE75-08 — Monroe County Circuit Court Case 75

Repository source · SHA-256 149f897c082767330a08c3787e8b8c5a1ec80e158eb80f75af4b760999903482
Sources for the expanded narrative
- National Archives, Confederate compiled service records, M268, roll 126: John Kirkland, Company B, 3rd Tennessee Infantry; all nineteen images are reproduced above.
- Guion Miller Eastern Cherokee applications #26494, #33702, #8597 and #33726, with Special Commissioner testimony of June 26, 1908, M685, roll 7; use the linked family exhibits for the specific statements.
- Tennessee State Library and Archives, Monroe County Circuit Court, State v. John Kirkland et al., Case No. 75, 1866–1867; indictment, process and witness-cost records.
- Tennessee Confederate pension application S3751, October 1901, including its rejection and supporting statements; all five images are reproduced above.
- Shaw military and pension records, including Bazel Shaw’s retained service jacket, NARA RG 109, M268 roll 336, item 181086393, master pp. 634–641. For James and William, the newly checked NPS transcription and its identity limits appear in the brothers’ section.
- Bill Baker, “Affair at Toqua”, and the illustrated grave markers: retrospective accounts are distinguished from contemporary records.
Family relationship: Grade B. The narrative distinguishes documented service and legal proceedings from later attributions of particular acts.
The court order found: 13 May 1868
On 13 May 1868, Monroe Circuit Court placed Anna Rodgers murder Case 75 against John and William Kirkland and others on the retired docket after repeated arrest writs were returned with the defendants not found. The State of Tennessee was ordered to pay the costs. This is a documented procedural disposition, not a conviction, acquittal, pardon or nolle prosequi in Case 75. No later reopening or merits judgment was established by the targeted searches; a separate retired-docket register was not retrieved.
Read the 16-page illustrated supplement · Master pp. 933–948. Full original scans are linked below; the existing indictment and 1867 return remain in the earlier source section.
What the minutes establish
- 14 September 1866: a nolle prosequi applied to G. K. Roberts only, conditional on securing costs; further arrest process was ordered for the remaining defendants.
- 11 September 1867: the murder prosecution received another alias capias.
- 14 January 1868: robbery No. 59 was discontinued; murder No. 75 received another arrest writ.
- 13 May 1868: murder No. 75 was removed from the active docket and placed on the retired docket because the defendants had not been found. Tennessee was ordered to pay costs.
Labeled enlargement of the entry at the bottom of manuscript p. 23; click for the complete, unaltered original spread. DGS 008478542, image 403.Reading transcription of the order
Caption: The State v. John and William Kirkland and others. No. 75. Line breaks and punctuation normalized; canceled drafting words omitted. The original scan controls.
In this case it appearing to the Court, that more than one capias has issued in this case and been returned by the Sheriff, the defendants not found. It is therefore ordered by the Court that this cause be stricken from the docket and placed upon the retired docket. It is therefore considered by the Court, that the State of Tennessee pay the cost of this cause, and that the Clerk make out and certify the bill of costs, for the inspection of the Court and attorney General.
Mexican War service remains unproved
Fifth Tennessee Mexican War service remains unproved. The correct compiled-service series is NARA M638 roll 13, Fifth Tennessee Infantry A-K (DGS 005412812), not rolls 14-15. The final William A. King card at image 2559 is immediately followed by Alfred Kite at image 2560, with no intervening Kirkland/Kirklin jacket. Similar-name Louisiana and North Carolina index cards lack an identity bridge to John Jackson Kirkland. This bounded negative search does not prove lifelong non-service.
What remains open
Targeted name searches in the 1873–1889 minute books did not establish a reopening of Case 75. Those searches were not a page-by-page audit; the 1889–1904 books were not examined, and no separate retired-docket register was retrieved. The 1870 retired-docket entry for robbery No. 350, J. Kirkland and Jo. Philips, is a different prosecution. No later verdict or pardon is claimed. John remains a collateral relative at Grade B; no ancestry grade, service badge or family count changes.
Original scans and source captions
14 September 1866: Roberts nolle prosequi — Monroe Circuit minutes, p. 51 (right leaf), DGS 008478542, image 73. The discontinuance is expressly as to Roberts; an alias capias is ordered for the balance. Full original scan · Archival source
11 September 1867: renewed process, first part — DGS 008478542, image 296. Murder entry begins at the bottom of p. 493; continuation is at the top of p. 494 in the next image. Full original scan · Archival source
11 September 1867: renewed process, continuation — DGS 008478542, image 297. Top of p. 494 continues the murder entry and awards an alias capias returnable to the next term. Full original scan · Archival source
14 January 1868: two different cases — DGS 008478542, image 357, p. 615. Robbery No. 59 receives a nolle prosequi; murder No. 75 receives another alias capias. Do not conflate them. Full original scan · Archival source
13 May 1868: Case 75 placed on retired docket — DGS 008478542, image 403, p. 23 (right leaf, bottom). The number 75 and John and William Kirkland are explicit. This is the disposition established by this investigation. Full original scan · Archival source
12 January 1870: separate robbery case — DGS 008478542, image 556, p. 327. Caption J. Kirkland and Jo. Philips, robbery No. 350, placed on retiring docket. This is not Anna Rodgers Case 75. Full original scan · Archival source
Manuscript K surname index — DGS 008478542, image 41. Separate lines for robbery and murder direct the reader to the respective minute entries. Full original scan · Archival source
Fifth Tennessee: William A. King, final card — NARA M638, roll 13; FamilySearch DGS 005412812, image 2559. Immediately precedes Alfred Kite. This card belongs to King, not John Kirkland. Full original scan · Archival source
Fifth Tennessee: Alfred Kite jacket — NARA M638, roll 13; DGS 005412812, image 2560. No Kirkland/Kirklin folder intervenes between King and Kite in this sequence. Full original scan · Archival source
Index: John D. Kirkland, Louisiana — Federal general index card: Company G, 1 Louisiana Infantry, second lieutenant. A Louisiana record, not proof of Fifth Tennessee service. Full original scan · Archival source
Index: John D. Kirkland, Louisiana militia — Federal general index card: Company A, 3 Louisiana Militia Infantry, private. Identity with the subject is not established. Full original scan · Archival source
Index reference: J. H. Kirkland / Hampton Kirklin — Federal reference card directs the reader to an original filed under Kirklin, Hampton; Company A, 1 North Carolina Volunteers. No identity bridge to John Jackson Kirkland was found. Full original scan · Archival sourceKirkland and Shaw: recovered research review
Mexican War service remains unproved
Fifth Tennessee Mexican War service remains unproved. The correct compiled-service series is NARA M638 roll 13, Fifth Tennessee Infantry A-K (DGS 005412812), not rolls 14-15. The final William A. King card at image 2559 is immediately followed by Alfred Kite at image 2560, with no intervening Kirkland/Kirklin jacket. Similar-name Louisiana and North Carolina index cards lack an identity bridge to John Jackson Kirkland. This bounded negative search does not prove lifelong non-service.
Case 75: retired docket, 13 May 1868
On 13 May 1868, Monroe Circuit Court placed Anna Rodgers murder Case 75 against John and William Kirkland and others on the retired docket after repeated arrest writs were returned with the defendants not found. The State of Tennessee was ordered to pay the costs. This is a documented procedural disposition, not a conviction, acquittal, pardon or nolle prosequi in Case 75. No later reopening or merits judgment was established by the targeted searches; a separate retired-docket register was not retrieved.
The three Shaw men remain distinct
George Bazel Shaw is retained as a former Confederate soldier whose later death is described in conflicting retrospective evidence. James Washington Shaw is the Union cavalryman reportedly killed by guerrillas. Jefferson Shaw is the pro-Union civilian; no military service is assigned to him. The recovered report does not justify identifying a specific killer or merging these three histories.
Family relationship and service
John and William Kirkland remain collateral relatives; the accepted family relationship stays Grade B. The detailed record, original service jacket, pension testimony and case papers already occupy master pp. 742-814 and 904-913. The NPS transcription now confirms the James and William entries; full civilian identities and original-card comparison are addressed in the updated brothers’ section.
Original orders now inspected
The 14 September 1866 nolle prosequi applies to G. K. Roberts only. On 14 January 1868, robbery No. 59 was discontinued while murder No. 75 received another arrest writ. The 1870 retirement of robbery No. 350 is also separate. The new court and military exhibits, transcription and search limits follow on master pp. 933-948; the earlier indictment and return remain on pp. 811-812.
Recovered research and its evidence limits