Return to the complete family register

Genealogy evidence review

Historical Halloween review: at that date, 140 admitted ancestors plus Clark, 18 held profiles, a 737-page private master, six Revolutionary Patriots, six Confederate and two Union ancestors. Current totals and subsequent admissions appear above.

Samuel Lenderman

Generation 6 · Grade B · historical front register p.14

The 1850 and 1870 Samuel/Eliza household identities, nearby David Mitchel/Michel and the 1866 probate place the family on the Wilkes–Polk–Cherokee route. In 1860 Sarah 9 follows Samuel 40, Eliza 37 and David 11. In 1867 Sarah Lenderman marries James Whitten Hollingshead (retained master p. 196); in 1870 Sarah 18, born Tennessee, is with James in Beaverdam, where Samuel and Eliza also live. The compatible age, uncommon surname, family migration and local marriage form a cumulative Grade B identification with the admitted Sarah. This conclusion does not depend on Argon’s erroneous younger-child lists.

The 1860 surname looks Landers; children’s birthplace cells are blank and the p. 117 continuation differs substantially from Argon. Census household order is not an explicit biological relationship. The William and Henry comparisons are bounded, not an exhaustive exclusion of all families. Sarah’s precise birth and death remain unresolved: retain the master’s reported 1882 death without adopting the unsupported 1872–1875 range. No relationship is inferred solely from the 1900 eleven-child total.

Documented proof page

Eliza Jane Mikel / Michael Lenderman

Generation 6 · Grade B · historical front register p.14

The 1850 and 1870 Samuel/Eliza household identities, nearby David Mitchel/Michel and the 1866 probate place the family on the Wilkes–Polk–Cherokee route. In 1860 Sarah 9 follows Samuel 40, Eliza 37 and David 11. In 1867 Sarah Lenderman marries James Whitten Hollingshead (retained master p. 196); in 1870 Sarah 18, born Tennessee, is with James in Beaverdam, where Samuel and Eliza also live. The compatible age, uncommon surname, family migration and local marriage form a cumulative Grade B identification with the admitted Sarah. This conclusion does not depend on Argon’s erroneous younger-child lists. The 1841 bond to Eliza Mikel precedes Sarah’s probable birth; Eliza remains with Samuel in 1850, 1860, 1870 and 1900. Sarah Michael’s will names Eliza Jane Lenderman. Together these support biological maternity at Grade B, rather than assigning every woman in a household as a mother.

The 1860 surname looks Landers; children’s birthplace cells are blank and the p. 117 continuation differs substantially from Argon. Census household order is not an explicit biological relationship. The William and Henry comparisons are bounded, not an exhaustive exclusion of all families. Sarah’s precise birth and death remain unresolved: retain the master’s reported 1882 death without adopting the unsupported 1872–1875 range. No relationship is inferred solely from the 1900 eleven-child total. The bond is not a separate marriage return; 59 years in 1900 approximates 1841. Eliza’s NC/KY birthplace conflict remains.

Documented proof page

Leonard Lenderman

Generation 7 · Grade B · historical front register p.15

The 1843 estate settlement groups equal allocations under Amount of Each Childs Shear and includes Samuel Lenderman. Samuel’s 1839 co-obligation for Dolly Lindermon and David Bumgarner, the latter’s estate share, and the Samuel/William Polk adjacency support identification of the distributee with the later Samuel. Malinda Wilcoxson’s later Beaverdam residence adds a corroborating married-family association. This is strong Grade B paternal correlation, not merely treating an estate purchaser as a son.

The distributee list includes spouses/representatives; it does not individually label every payee a biological son. Samuel’s identity is correlated across records. Ann is documented as widow but is not admitted as Samuel’s mother. Her proposed Fyffe surname and Leonard’s proposed Henry/John Henry father remain unproved. No exact 1779 birth or exact February death day is adopted.

Documented proof page

Sarah Michael / Micheal / Mitchel

Generation 7 · Grade A/B · historical front register p.15

The court-certified copy of the 9 May 1866 will explicitly calls Eliza Jane Lenderman my Daughter and rewards her care. The July 1866 probate minute names Samuel Lenderman as the presenter. The unusual full name, locality and Samuel’s participation identify the daughter with Samuel’s wife Eliza Jane. Explicit daughter evidence is Grade A; the identity correlation is A/B. Descent to Clark still passes through the Grade B Sarah Lenderman connection.

The surviving image is a 1868 court-certified copy, not the original signed 1866 paper. The estate packet’s Chattes/Chattis catalog label is not adopted as a proved personal alias. Other children are unnamed in the will. No husband, maiden surname, parents or inferred military ancestry is added.

Documented proof page

Knowles and Harden decisions

This earlier review held five colonial candidates and the proposed parents of adult Mike Harden. The colonial five were subsequently admitted through the correlated Grade B Bethenia Harding–Perkins bridge; the proposed parents of adult Mike Harden remain held. Neither an estate-distribution rule nor a recurring name alone establishes parentage.

Harden review · Colonial evidence decision · New refutation reviewed · Phase VII dossier reconciliation

Original-record exhibits

L01 — Samuel and Eliza marriage bond
Wilkes County, North Carolina; 13 May 1841; Samuel Lenderman and Eliza Mikel. Robert Gray is the co-obligor, not the J. J. Bryan alleged by Argon.
Repository record

L02 — Samuel and Eliza in 1850
1850 U.S. census, Polk County, Tennessee, 3rd Civil District; 23 November; manuscript/stamped 527, printed 264; dwelling 993/family 1002. Samuel 30, Eliza 30; Mary 7, Merinda 5, Mariah 3, David 3/12; David Mitchel 21. Names are reading transcriptions.
Repository record

L03 — Samuel, Eliza, David and Sarah in 1860
1860 U.S. census, Polk County, Tennessee, 7th District, Benton post office, 15 August, p. 116, dwelling/family 788, lines 37-40. Samuel 40, Eliza 37, David 11, Sarah 9. Surname looks Landers; child birthplaces are blank.
Repository record

L04 — 1860 continuation and household uncertainty
Same enumeration, p. 117. Continuation begins Martha 25, James 5, Eliza 3, Mariett 2 and Mary 6/12 before household 789. These are not the Sophrona and Samuel list supplied by Argon. Relationships are unstated.
Repository record

L05 — Sarah Hollingshead in 1870
1870 U.S. census, Beaverdam Township, Cherokee County, North Carolina, Murphy post office, 4 July, p. 13, dwelling 73/family 74, lines 34-36: James 26, Sarah 18, William 1. The dossier claim of John 2 and Samuel 5/12 is not on this page.
Repository record

L06 — Samuel and Eliza in Beaverdam
1870 U.S. census, Beaverdam Township, Cherokee County, North Carolina, 7 July, p. 18, dwelling 132/family 133: Samuel 51, Eliza 48, David 20, Scott 13, Bethany 12, Thomas 11, Carolina 8, Rebecca 6. Eliza is recorded born Kentucky.
Repository record

L07 — Sarah Michael names her daughter
Cherokee County, North Carolina, estate packet catalogued Chattes/Chattis, Sarah, 1867; image 15/35. Will dated 9 May 1866, court-certified copy 23 September 1868. Names daughter Eliza Jane Lenderman; unspecified children share land proceeds.
Repository record

L08 — Samuel presents Sarah Michael’s will
Same packet, image 16/35; copied July 1866 minute, docket p. 45. Samuel Lenderman presents the will. His son-in-law status is a correlation, not an express phrase in the minute.
Repository record

L09 — Leonard’s estate distribution
Wilkes County, North Carolina, Leonard Lenderman estate packet, May Term 1843 settlement, packet image 9/22. Heading Amount of Each Childs Shear and $159.45 allocations include Samuel, William, Henry, Caroline and married-family distributees.
Repository record

L10 — Dolly Lindermon and David Bumgarner bond
Wilkes County, North Carolina, marriage bond 2 July 1839. Samuel is a co-obligor. The bond proves association, not expressly brotherhood.

L11 — Malinda Wilcoxson in Beaverdam
1870 U.S. census, Beaverdam Township, Cherokee County, North Carolina, p. 17; comparison with Samuel’s nearby household. Proximity supports the migration correlation; it does not itself state kinship.

L12 — Samuel and Eliza in 1900
1900 U.S. census, Beaverdam Township, Cherokee County, North Carolina, ED 13, sheet 7B, 18 June, dwelling 230/family 232, lines 89-90. Samuel November 1818; Eliza March 1822; reported 59 years married; Eliza 11 children born, 8 living. These totals do not identify Sarah among the deceased.
Repository record

L13 — Winfield Scott’s retrospective parent report
North Carolina death certificate, Cherokee County, Beaverdam, Winfield Scott Lenderman, death 23 October 1914, filed 12 November. Parents Samuel Lenderman and Jane Mikel; informant H.E.Crain. Conflicting birth information is preserved. This is not a Tennessee certificate dated 29 October.

L14 — William’s comparison household
1860 U.S. census, Monroe County, Tennessee, 18th Civil District, Sweet Water post office, p. 252, dwelling 1823/family 1843. William 39, Elisabeth 38, Appa 19 and Rattery Daugherty 35. This is a bounded comparison, not proof that William never had a daughter Sarah.

L15 — Henry’s comparison household
1860 U.S. census, Wilkes County, North Carolina, Upper Division, Lower Division post office, 21 July, p. 90, dwelling/family 663. H.Lenderman 51, Mary 51, Elizabeth 20, Lander 18, Mary 12. No Sarah of the target age in this household.

C01 — Thomas Harding’s actual will
Henrico County, Virginia, Wills and Deeds No.1, part 2, p. 301; 10 March 1728/9; proved first Monday April 1731; DGS 007645095, image 335. Names sons William and Thomas, daughter Mary Thomas, wife/executrix Mary. No rest-of-my-children clause.
Repository record

C02 — Actual Goochland page142
Goochland County, Virginia, Order Book 4, pp. 142-143, May 1737; DGS 007898185, image 639. Does not contain the asserted Bethenia Perkins/Thomas Harding paired attendance order.
Repository record

C03 — Located Perkins witness-fee order
Goochland Order Book 4, pp. 150-151, May 1737; DGS 007898185, image 643. Nicholas Pirkins is awarded 250 pounds tobacco for ten days as witness for Nicholas Giles against Anthony Hoggatt. Not Bethenia; no kinship stated.
Repository record

C04 — William Giles’s will
Henrico Deeds and Wills 1688-1697, pp. 475-476; 11 July 1692, proved 2 April 1694; DGS 007676115, image 535. Names wife Bethany and daughter Mary, with sons William, John, Nicholas. The claimed Tuckahoe land division is not this will’s wording.
Repository record

C05 — Bethaniah Giles identifies her father
Henrico Deeds and Wills 1688-1697, p. 35; acknowledgment 1 February 1688/89; DGS 007676115, image 304. William Giles’s wife Bethaniah is sole daughter and heiress of Capt John Knowles; inherited land conveyed to John Crowly.
Repository record

C06 — John Knowles’s will
Henrico Miscellaneous Records 1650-1807, vol.1, p. 49; mounted manuscript, DGS 007898202, image 30; will dated 5 February 1675/76. Names daughter Bethania and son William. Faint passages remain qualified.
Repository record

C07 — John Knowles’s probate endorsement
Same volume, p. 50; DGS 007898202, image 31. Probate and recording 1 June 1676. This fixes death before that date, not an exact death day.
Repository record