OPERATION EUBANK PATERNITY — EVIDENCE REPORT Research date: 8 November 2026 (America/New_York) VERDICT John Eubank of Albemarle County, Virginia, testator of 24 March 1789, is supported at STRONG B as the father of the accepted Elizabeth Eubank Fortune (#329), wife of Thomas Fortune (#328). His proposed position is #658, seventh great-grandfather. The recorded will directly establishes that he had a daughter Betty Fortun. The identification of that daughter with the user's accepted Elizabeth rests on correlation, described below; it is not withheld merely because the will does not name her husband. This is one qualifying parentage finding, not an automatic addition to the master. The 970-page master and complete list of 163 admitted ancestors were not available for a duplication audit. Thus John is a candidate for ONE genuinely new admission if not already present elsewhere. No master, site, ancestor count, or Patriot count was changed. The supplied baseline remains 163 ancestors and nine Revolutionary Patriots. Hannah is proved to have been John's wife in March 1789. Her biological maternity of Elizabeth remains a supported hypothesis, not a second B-level admission on the evidence assembled here. Neither parent's own parents are established. Do not attach Majors, Mason, Elizabeth Raines, or an earlier John Eubank as proven ancestors. Do not attach the suffix Jr. or a circa-1730 birth as established facts. PRIMARY RECORDS RECOVERED AND VISUALLY INSPECTED All six JPG files in this packet are original-size downloads of microfilmed courthouse record-book pages, not generated images. These are recorded copies of the instruments, not demonstrated surviving autograph originals. FamilySearch catalog 279536 identifies the underlying records as microfilm of originals at the Albemarle County Courthouse, Charlottesville, Virginia. Film 30212; digital image group 007643846; item 2, Will Book 3 (1785–1798). Catalog: https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/catalog/279536 1. John Eubank will: Albemarle County, Virginia, Will Book 3, pp.70–71; executed 24 March 1789. FamilySearch, image 289 of 433 in the complete image group. https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89P7-97J9 File: John-Eubank-Will-Book-3-pp70-71.jpg (5544 x 3850 pixels). The will begins at the bottom of p.70 and occupies p.71. The upper part of p.70 concerns William Harris's estate and is NOT Eubank evidence. 2. Eubank probate endorsement: same volume, p.72, July Court 1789; image 290 of 433. https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89P7-97NN File: John-Eubank-Probate-Book-3-pp72-73.jpg (5493 x 3853). Only the top of p.72 is Eubank's probate. George Murrell's will follows, then another estate. Do not assign their provisions to Eubank. 3. Eubank inventory and appraisal: same volume, pp.86–87; image 297 of 433. https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89P7-97VY File: John-Eubank-Inventory-Appraisal-pp86-87.jpg (5530 x 3891). The inventory is dated 10 May 1789 and returned at October Court 1789. The appraisal cites an order of 9 July 1789 and was also returned at October Court. The top of p.86 concludes Susannah Carroll's will; Eubank's inventory begins below it. 4. Volume's C–F index, image 249 of 433. https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89P7-97VT File: Albemarle-Will-Book-3-E-F-index.jpg (5285 x 3894). It lists John Eubank's will at 70, an inventory entry whose number appears 80, and appraisal at 87. The actual inventory was found and verified on 86–87. The visually verified page takes precedence over the index's ambiguous or erroneous number. The common citation '3:71' points to the dispositive page, but the full will/probate citation is 3:70–72. 5. John Fortune will: same volume, pp.98–100, executed 13 September 1789, proved September Court 1790. Images 303–304 of 433. https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89P7-97JJ https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89P7-97JX Files: John-Fortune-Will-Book-3-pp98-99.jpg (5473 x 3828); John-Fortune-Will-Probate-pp100-101.jpg (5509 x 3823). John Fortune names Thomas and William as sons, along with Williamson and Richard; Thomas and William are also executors with Nicholas Hamner. A deceased son Benjamin is represented by grandsons Benjamin and John. This independently confirms Thomas and William's sibling relationship, but does not name their wives. John Fenwick's preceding will and Thomas Emmerson's following will are separate instruments. EUBANK WILL — WORKING TRANSCRIPTION Editorial method: manually checked against the downloaded manuscript. Paragraph breaks and limited punctuation added for readability; original personal-name forms retained. Brackets mark editorial uncertainty or a reading compromised by the lower page edge. This is a working transcription, not a certified diplomatic edition. The record's historical terminology is preserved when transcribed. [p.70, beginning below Harris probate] In the Name of God Amen I John Eubank of Albemarle County & State of Virginia being in an imperfect State of body tho in perfect Mind & memory Knowing that it is appointed for all Men once to die Do make & ordain this my last Will & Testament that is to say principally & first of all I give and Recommend my soul into the hands of Almighty God that gave it & my body to the Earth to be buried in a decent Christian Manner at the Discretion of my Exors hoping at the general Resurrection to Receive the same by the mighty power of God and as touching such worldly Estate as it hath pleased God to bless me with in this life [lower-edge reading] [p.71] I give demise and dispose of the same in the following Manner & Form. I Will that all my Just debts be paid in Convenient time after my Decease. I Will that my Orange Tract of Lands be sold & divided between my two sons John & James Eubanks giving unto John Two parts & James one & my Hardware Tract to be Equally divided between said John & James Eubank. The Tract whereon I now live of one hundred & sixty four Acres I give unto my Son William. My Seventy Acre Tract of land Joining Moor I give unto my Daughter Nancy Eubank Together with a Negroe Boy called Phill & Mare Colt called Fancy & the Bed she hath in possession To her & her Heirs forever. I give unto my son John Eubank one Negroe woman Called Phillis & my old Still to him & his Heirs forever. I give unto my son James Eubank one Negroe boy Pompy & my new Still to him & his Heirs forever. I give unto my son William Eubank one Negroe Fellow Frank & my blue Rugg bed & Furniture & Young mare called Pillis. I lend unto my Daughter Betty Fortun Fifty pounds Cash during her natural life & at her decease to Return to my heirs And in like manner I lend unto my Daughter Sarah Fortun Fifty pounds. Item I give unto my Daughter Franky Gilmer fifty pounds to her & her Heirs forever. I give unto my wife Hannah Eubank a Duch Feather bed and Furniture & a Mare Called Philley. The Balance of my horse Kind & Stock of all sorts together with the Balance of my household Furniture & plantation utensils are to be sold & divided between five of my Children Namely John, James, William, Franky & Nancy (Together with all the Remains of my Fortune) giving to John & James Ten pounds a peace in that Division more than the others. I give unto my son William my large Dutch gun. I give unto my friend Samuel Murrell my small Smooth bore gun & Lastly I do hereby Constitute & appoint Samuel Murrell John Eubank & James Eubank Executors to this my last Will & Testament & I Do hereby utterly disallow Revoke & disannul all & every other former Testaments Wills Legacies bequests & Executors, by me in any wise before Named or Willed Rattifying & Confirming the within & no other to be my last Will & Testament. In Witness whereof I have hereunto Set my hand & Seal this twenty fourth day of March in the year one thousand seven hundred & Eighty nine. Sealed & declared by the sd John Eubank to be his last Will & Testament. In Presence of us John [Mitton?] George [his mark] Eubank William [Mitton?] John Eubank [seal] Transcription notes: the two witness surnames need another paleographic check against contemporary signatures; do not silently normalize them to Milton or Melton. The witness George signs by mark in the recorded form. The testator's name is recorded without Jr. Names of the mares are transcribed as they appear and are less consequential than the family clauses. 'Fortun' is the reading of both daughters' surname; the automated transcript's 'Porter' is erroneous. The phrase 'Remains of my Fortune' concerns his estate, not an additional person named Fortune. PROBATE — WORKING TRANSCRIPTION, p.72 At Albemarle July Court 1789 This last Will & Testament of John Eubank deceased was produced into Court and proved by the oaths of John [Mitton?] & George Eubank two of the witnesses thereto & ordered to be Recorded & probat of the same was granted Samuel Murrell one of the Executors therein Named who gave bond & Security according to law. John Nicholas C C INVENTORY AND APPRAISAL — EXTRACTS AND ABSTRACT p.86 heading: 'An Inventory of the Estate of John Eubank Deceased May the 10th 1789'. p.87 certification: 'The above is a perfect Inventory taken by the Executors' followed by Samuel Murrell, John Eubank, James Eubank. p.87 return: 'At Albemarle October Court 1789'; inventory returned and ordered recorded, John Nicholas, clerk. The appraisal explicitly refers to the county court's order bearing date July 9th 1789. The appraisers' names read John Wharton, Mark Leak, and Samuel Anderson. Its October 1789 return is at the foot of p.87. The inventory lists four enslaved people without individual names, beds, furniture, implements, two stills, firearms, livestock, and other household items. It is not a distribution naming Betty or Sarah. Its connection to the will is reinforced by the exact three executor names, chronology, and matching types of property. No additional direct ancestor is proved by the inventory. Full images are supplied; this report does not pretend to provide a line-for-line transcription of every utensil or valuation. DEATH-DATE CORRECTION 24 March 1789 is the will's execution date. He was deceased when the inventory was taken on 10 May 1789. Therefore use 'died on or after 24 March 1789 and by 10 May 1789, Albemarle County, Virginia' as the supported interval. July 1789 is probate, not death. A death specifically on March 24 is not proved. The interval allows death later on the day of execution; it does not require survival beyond that day. CORRELATED IDENTITY ARGUMENT — WHY STRONG B The accepted starting identity is Elizabeth Eubank, wife of Thomas Fortune and mother of Zachariah. That downstream lineage was supplied as admitted and is not independently re-proved here. The contemporary recorded will establishes John of Albemarle as father of Betty Fortun and Sarah Fortun, with wife Hannah and five further children: John, James, William, Nancy and Franky Gilmer. Woods's 1901 account describes the same county, Hardware locality, 1789 death, wife Hannah, and distinctive seven-child cluster. It calls the daughter Elizabeth and describes Elizabeth and Sarah as wives of Fortune brothers. The agreement across the full cluster strongly identifies Woods's family with the actual testator; it is substantially more than a shared common name. Betty/Elizabeth is a compatible familiar-name pairing, but that naming convention alone is not the proof. Baldridge's family account expressly connects Elizabeth to Thomas Fortune and the Zachariah-containing family. It acknowledges reliance on Woods for the Eubank origin account. That dependence limits its weight: do not count Woods and Baldridge as two wholly independent attestations of parentage. Nevertheless, its explicit identification of the Fortune spouse and descendant family supplies a specific published bridge to the accepted identity, and its family description matches the recovered will. John Fortune's independent will establishes that Thomas and William were brothers, consistent with the reported marriage pattern. The conclusion is Strong B historical parentage for John -> accepted Elizabeth, with direct evidence for John -> Betty and correlated identification for Betty -> Elizabeth, wife of Thomas. It is not represented as exhaustive Genealogical Proof Standard completion or genetic proof. No DNA evidence was obtained. No examined record suggests Betty was a stepdaughter or adopted daughter; 'my Daughter' is ordinary contemporary parentage evidence, rather than a reason to demand unattainable explicit biological terminology. The principal residual identification risk is that the later author assigned the wrong Fortune husband to one of the two sisters. Additional marriage, consent, or estate-receipt evidence could strengthen or revise that identification. This risk warrants B rather than claiming an entirely primary-record A-level chain; it does not reduce the entire finding to an unsupported lead. HANNAH — SEPARATE MATERNITY ASSESSMENT Hannah's marriage to the testator is directly established in 1789. Baldridge expressly calls Elizabeth a daughter of John and Hannah; Woods identifies Hannah as the wife and the children as John's. The maternal assertion therefore has positive secondary support. However, no record examined places Hannah with John at Elizabeth's birth or establishes the duration of their marriage; no independent maternal-family, marriage, or inheritance correlation was found. The will and inventory independently verify John but do not independently corroborate Baldridge's maternal attribution. On this record set I do not grade maternity Strong B. This is an assessment of the supporting evidence's independence and chronological reach, not a requirement that a document use the words 'biological mother.' No evidence of a different mother was found, and none is asserted. CONFLICTS AND SAME-NAME MEN 1. Caroline probate in 1737: a published extraction of Caroline Order Books reports John Eubank's will presented 13 May 1737 by Elizabeth and William Eubank, with inventory returned 10 June. A man already deceased in 1737 cannot be the Albemarle testator executing a will in 1789. He also cannot father a child born circa 1745 unless that birth estimate is substantially wrong. The original Caroline pages were not inspected in this run; the extraction is a derivative source and is identified as such. 2. Caroline probate in December 1778: the same extraction reports a deceased John, witnesses James Carter and James Fletcher, and executors John and George Eubank; appraisal returned April 1779. This is incompatible with the 1789 testator's life, dates, and executors Samuel Murrell, John and James. A possible earlier ancestral relationship between these families remains unproved. Shared John/George names do not bridge it. Source for both: https://ancestraljourneys.website/carolineorderbooks.htm Related discussion: https://ancestraljourneys.website/eubank2_newman_amherst.htm 3. Birth c.1730: no examined primary record supplies a birth year. With Elizabeth's accepted c.1745 birth, c.1730 implies fatherhood around age fifteen; possible, but a warning against adopting the estimate without evidence. The will does not prove a birth in Orange. It proves ownership of an Orange tract. Birth, prior residence, and land ownership are different propositions. 4. Woods's suggested 1746 Rocky Creek patentee: Woods treats that identification as possible, not certain. Do not promote it to established identity, and do not use it to invent John's parents or birth date. The 1759 Matthew Jordan purchase is a specific deed lead, but its original has not been inspected here. 5. Sarah's husband: a FamilySearch public profile assigns William; a Virginia SAR burial compilation assigns Benjamin. Neither of the two probate instruments inspected names Sarah's husband. John Fortune's will confirms that both William and the deceased Benjamin belong to his family, so the bare statement 'Fortune brothers' does not by itself settle which brother married Sarah. Sarah's marriage pairing remains unresolved in this report and is not necessary to invent in order to support John's paternity of Betty. Profile: https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/LHVG-X31/sarah-eubank-1750-1803 Conflicting compilation, printed p.143: https://www.virginiasar.org/assets/PROGRAMS/AMERICAN_HERITAGE/2nd%20Edition%20VASSAR%20Rev%20War%20Burial%20Book%20Sep%2016%202022%20without%20illlustrations%20%282%29.pdf 6. Hannah's surname and John's parents: online trees supply incompatible Majors/Mason and John/Elizabeth Raines combinations. None is established by this will. No extra generations are recommended. The absence of Jr. from this instrument does not prove he never used it; it means this record cannot validate that suffix or a father-son namesake inference. PUBLISHED SOURCES ACTUALLY REVIEWED Edgar Woods, Albemarle County in Virginia (Charlottesville: Michie Company, 1901), pp.188–189. Both page images were downloaded and visually inspected. Page 188 supplies the family cluster and geographic account; p.189 continues the later James Eubank descendants and supplies no parent identification for the 1789 testator. The two PNG pages are included in the packet. https://archive.org/details/cu31924028785703 Direct scan: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/46/Albemarle_County_in_Virginia%3B_giving_some_account_of_what_it_was_by_nature%2C_of_what_it_was_made_by_man%2C_and_of_some_of_the_men_who_made_it_%28IA_cu31924028785703%29.pdf Blanche Hamlett Baldridge, My Virginia Kin (Strawberry Point, Iowa: Press-Journal Publishing Co., cataloged 1958), Eubank section, page marked 156, and Fortune section pp.160–161. Internet Archive scan PDF pages 325, 333 and 335, respectively; scan has intervening blank images. These pages were downloaded and visually inspected. The index points some Eubank names to 155, while the chapter leaf bears a handwritten 156; identify the chapter title and scan page as well as the page number to avoid ambiguity. The Eubank account explicitly connects Elizabeth with Thomas and John/Hannah, but cites Woods for origins. The Fortune section lists Zachariah among their children and reports Jesse's 1793 marriage with both parents' consent. It also supplies tax leads: Thomas's 1799 Amherst landholding of 1,098 acres and seven enslaved people on the personal tax list. Those tax facts are reported secondary evidence, not original tax images inspected here. The 1793 consent is a promising original-record bridge; it has not been obtained in this run. https://archive.org/details/myvirginiakincom00bald https://archive.org/download/myvirginiakincom00bald/myvirginiakincom00bald.pdf Catalog: https://openlibrary.org/books/OL5806596M/My_Virginia_kin 1978 Family Findings/TNGenWeb compilation independently located, but not assumed independent in information: it repeats John/Hannah parentage and points to Thomas Fortune's Amherst Will Book 4, p.160, probate 15 October 1804, inventory p.165. This web page is a compiled discussion, not an original contemporaneous Bible entry for Elizabeth's parents. https://www.tngenweb.org/records/madison/bibles/ff/bible78.htm REMAINING ARCHIVAL TARGETS — EXACTLY WHAT IS AND IS NOT FINISHED The core will, probate, indexed inventory/appraisal and supporting Fortune will have been recovered. A complete loose-estate packet, all later settlements, original deeds, tax lists, and a complete surname-wide county search have NOT been completed. No claim is made that the estate lacks other papers or that all alternatives have been exhausted. The archive viewer was accessible; these remaining items are unfinished research, not a demonstrated access prohibition. A. Best identity-strengthening target: Amherst County, Virginia, Thomas Fortune will, Will Book 4, p.160, probate reportedly 15 October 1804; inventory p.165. Obtain the full will and continuation and compare the wife and eight-child cluster. Also obtain Jesse Fortune–Betsy Lavender marriage consent, reported 22 July 1793, naming Thomas and Elizabeth. These are specific references reported in the reviewed publications, not manuscript facts verified here. B. Best maternal/earlier-generation target: trace the exact land in John Eubank's will. Orange tract to be sold, proceeds two-thirds John and one-third James; Hardware tract divided equally between those sons; 164-acre residence to William; 70 acres adjoining Moor to Nancy. Search 1789 onward Orange grantor indexes for the three executors and the two sons, and Albemarle conveyances for the 164- and 70-acre parcels. A recital of original acquisition, inheritance, or dower could identify prior family relationships. No deed-book page for these transfers is yet established. C. Albemarle Deed Book 2 (1758–1761), Matthew Jordan -> John Eubank, reportedly 1759. Library of Virginia Albemarle microfilm reel 1. Inspect the actual conveyance and any wife/dower acknowledgment, then chain title forward to the 1789 Hardware parcel. The matching acreage and boundaries matter more than the name alone. D. Albemarle land and personal-property tax lists 1782–1790: separate John the eventual decedent from his son, George's son John, and other same-name men. Compare acreage and estate transitions against the four parcels. University of Virginia identifies Albemarle personal-property books under Micfilm 7485 and deed books under Micfilm 7488; will books under Micfilm 7493. These holdings were located, but the original tax lists were not inspected. https://guides.lib.virginia.edu/c.php?g=514863&p=10734452 E. General Index to Wills No.1 (1744–1930), Library of Virginia reel 45; follow every John Eubank/Eubanks entry, including fiduciary settlements after 1789. FamilySearch catalog places the general index on film 30210 / DGS 007675959 and labels it available at a FamilySearch Center or affiliate library. The will-book images themselves were accessible remotely. Library of Virginia Will Book 3 is reel 34; this is a separate identifier from FamilySearch film 30212. https://www.lva.virginia.gov/collections/ccmf/VA/VA003 F. Albemarle loose wills, 1743–1928, Library of Virginia collection described here: https://search.arvasarchive.org/catalog/vi_vi02287 . The web fetch returned forbidden during this run, so no loose John Eubank folder or contents are claimed. Request the 1789 John Eubank probate papers, executor bond, inventory, appraisal and receipts, identifying Samuel Murrell, John and James Eubank. A receipt signed by Thomas Fortune for Betty's legacy would be particularly useful. No request has been sent. G. Sarah Eubank's marriage/estate evidence: look for William/Sarah and Benjamin/Sarah Fortune in deeds, receipts and marriage consents. Do not copy the incompatible compiled assignments into the master as settled facts. RESEARCH BOUNDARY AND ADMISSION RECOMMENDATION Recommend John Eubank of Albemarle (#658), birth unknown, death 24 March–10 May 1789, as a Strong B father of Elizabeth (#329), subject to checking whether he is already counted. Preserve Hannah as named wife with maternity unresolved, and preserve John's and Hannah's parents as unknown. The new proof concerns the specific Albemarle testator; it does not validate the entire online profile labeled John Eubank Jr. (1730–1789). No new Revolutionary service claim has been established. END OF REPORT