INDEPENDENT ENGLISH GRADE AUDIT — 11 NOVEMBER 2026 Scope: Michael of Dedham = the Winston child baptized6December1579, with the newly recovered EarlSoham1609baptism and Wilby1635marriage. DECISION I retain a probable identification short of a recommended StrongB admission on the current inspected corpus. This is not because an original English will or an explicit emigration statement is indispensable. The six-to-four spoon count across34years is compatible and is not a serious contradiction. The March1640tax and June1640arrival chronology are compatible. The1639/40Richardson issue does not automatically disqualify the1579Dedham identification. WHY THE IDENTIFICATION IS MORE THAN A NAME MATCH The1579original baptism establishes Michael with parentsMichael/Elizabeth. The1614will's published full transcript gives an adult sonMichael English land and a tipped pot with six silver spoons. DedhamMichael's1648will gives his eldestMichael a tipped pot and silver spoons, and the1649inventory independently confirms four spoons and the pot. The new1609EarlSohamoriginal names Michael/Alice as parents of Michael, matching the proposed immigrant parental pair and the Woburn son's reported age. Bartlett's research, published1936, independently regarded1579Michael as probably the immigrant. The combined chronology is coherent. WHAT IS ACTUALLY UNRESOLVED, BEYOND MISSING PAPER There are additional documented same-generation English Michaels in this very kin group. Baldwin1915p16, and the modern transcription of Bartlett/Palmer1936p301, report WilliamBaconofCoddenham's1610will naming: — Michael Bacon, son of his brother Richard Bacon; — Michael Bacon, son of his brother Thomas Bacon; — separately, William Bacon, son of his brother Michael Bacon. The first two are distinct from Michael, son of Michael, baptized1579. Their exact ages and later histories have not been established here, but they are genuine named cousins in the same Suffolk family, alive at the1610will event as represented by the abstracts. They are plausible alternatives for the otherwise-unidentified adultMichael who appears withAlice atEarlSoham in1607and1609. They are not proved rival immigrants, and their existence does not disprove the preferred1579identification. It does mean that the1609parent-pair cannot yet be counted as an independently identified1579household. The younger Michael, son ofJohn and grandson of the1614testator, is a different issue. Bartlett estimates his birth about1598; if that estimate and Woburn's reported1608/09age are sound, he is too young to father the Woburn man. He is therefore not a strong alternative for theDedham father. He remains relevant to the1624Michael/MaryJeve marriage and subsequentWinstonchildren. The realcousins above are the more pertinent older-generation alternatives. The objects favor the1579son, because that is the man to whom the1614testator gave them. Their American record preserves the object-types but not initials, a unique description, or their prior owner. We therefore have one substantive transatlantic discriminator, accompanied by coherent but as-yet unassigned household and age matches. There is no evidence that either cousin possessed the same objects, and no such claim is made. My remaining concern is identification among an observed local family cluster, rather than the abstract possibility that an unknown unrelated man existed. The1936article's probable judgment is evaluated scholarship and deserves weight. It does not constitute another independent transatlantic record where it relies on the same will objects and candidate family. The actual article was unavailable; a modern transcription was read. Likewise the quoted1995Richardson opinion is a traced adverse claim, not a verified proof of permanentEnglishresidence. AFebruary1640baptism alone cannot exclude a later1640immigration. HOW STRONGB COULD CLOSE WITHOUT A PERFECT SON STATEMENT A coherent reconstruction of Michael/Alice'sEarlSohamchildren corresponding to Dedham'sMichael/Daniel/John/Alice/Sarah, a land disposition identifying the1614beneficiary by later residence, or a discriminating sibling/nephew connection throughWilliamofSalem could establish the migration identity indirectly. The1610Coddenhamwill and the1611CoddenhamMichaelburial are specific means to test the two cousin alternatives, rather than demanding an impossible census of everyEnglishBacon. The Wilby22April1635MichaelBacon/MaryHubbert marriage is an additional real candidate for theWoburncouple, but needs its own child/property correlation. SALem COLLATERAL TEST COMPLETED AT PRINTED-PRIMARY LEVEL WilliamBacon's imperfect1653will and RebeccaBacon's1655will were recovered and read in the complete1916Essexprobate publication. Neither names MichaelofDedham or his sonsMichael/Daniel/John. A reported cousinJohnBacon inSavage'ssummary is not present in that full printedRebecca text; she names cousinsAnnePotter,RichardCherlcraft andJorgBedell. Underlying manuscript targets and complete readable transcripts are in Salem_William_Rebecca_probate_dossier.txt. This bounded unsuccessful test is not evidenceagainstbrotherhood. It supplies no additionalpositiveanchor. ROOT DECISION This is an independent recommendation, not a mandate that the principal investigator choose the same threshold. The fair positive argument forStrongB is the unusual repeated object legacy plus concordant generation, age, names and migration chronology. The fair reason to withhold is the still-unassignedEarlSohamfamily amid actual known contemporaryMichaelcousins, with the single transatlantic object correlation carrying most of the discriminatory burden. The current evidence supports a serious, testable preferred hypothesis, not an identified contradiction. Any final grade should state that distinction explicitly.